Black Exhaust Soot--What??
#1
Black Exhaust Soot--What??
My "R" is leaving black sooty exhaust droplets on my garage floor.
This is not the usual stuff that flies out the tailpipes--I get that. No, these daily start-up drippings come from both inlet pipes (pre-muffler) and pool into a nice black mess. After once again cleaning up the build-up so I don't track it into the house, I tried cinching up the inlet clamps (see pic). Both were already super-tight. I drop the Jag off at my dealer to take a peek. After looking it over, they tell me that they can't touch it due to warranty concerns. What? No reclamping? No heat-resistant sealant? No minor weld in a pinch? Nope. Nada. So I called Jaguar USA. They check around and call me back. "Sorry, but this is normal. The drippings you are seeing are just occurring at the lowest point in the exhaust." They end up telling me the same thing about invalidating my warranty and suggest a drip pan.
I've had my share of vehicles, as have many of you, but I haven't seen one of them pulling this trick. My garage floor is certainly no shining example of Mr. Clean, but come on. Really, Jaguar?
What do y'all think? Any of you have this happening?
This is not the usual stuff that flies out the tailpipes--I get that. No, these daily start-up drippings come from both inlet pipes (pre-muffler) and pool into a nice black mess. After once again cleaning up the build-up so I don't track it into the house, I tried cinching up the inlet clamps (see pic). Both were already super-tight. I drop the Jag off at my dealer to take a peek. After looking it over, they tell me that they can't touch it due to warranty concerns. What? No reclamping? No heat-resistant sealant? No minor weld in a pinch? Nope. Nada. So I called Jaguar USA. They check around and call me back. "Sorry, but this is normal. The drippings you are seeing are just occurring at the lowest point in the exhaust." They end up telling me the same thing about invalidating my warranty and suggest a drip pan.
I've had my share of vehicles, as have many of you, but I haven't seen one of them pulling this trick. My garage floor is certainly no shining example of Mr. Clean, but come on. Really, Jaguar?
What do y'all think? Any of you have this happening?
Last edited by deltagroup; 09-04-2014 at 01:12 AM. Reason: Clarification
#2
#3
#4
Thanks, Walt. A high-temp sealant was the resolution I proposed to the dealer.
#5
#7
Trending Topics
#9
Jag has said that in order to get the great exhaust note and the pops and crackles, they dump fuel into the exhaust stroke - so you get that down the chain and it leads to more soot due to the rich mix.
If you haven't had it with other cars, it is probably because most of the time they go out of their way to avoid this situation - and Jag has purposely engineered it in.
If you haven't had it with other cars, it is probably because most of the time they go out of their way to avoid this situation - and Jag has purposely engineered it in.
#10
#12
#14
#15
Jag has said that in order to get the great exhaust note and the pops and crackles, they dump fuel into the exhaust stroke - so you get that down the chain and it leads to more soot due to the rich mix.
If you haven't had it with other cars, it is probably because most of the time they go out of their way to avoid this situation - and Jag has purposely engineered it in.
If you haven't had it with other cars, it is probably because most of the time they go out of their way to avoid this situation - and Jag has purposely engineered it in.
#16
Thanks for the feedback. Y'all gave me some great insights, as I've come to expect on this forum.
Just to respond to some of your thoughts--
--Alexg, you reminded me that very few things in life are truly important. Black sooty exhaust isn't one of them.
--Philipintexas, the droppings happen immediately at cold start-up. Yes, the car runs rich, especially with the supercharger. Need to stay rich on boost to avoid detonation and other bad things. I purposely ran aggressively rich fuel maps on some of my turbo cars to ensure safety on the top-end.
--vic55, you're right. The soot will continue.
--Mulmur, just to clarify, those sooty droplets I described are not coming out of the tailpipes; they are dripping from the clamped connections of both inlet pipes just prior to entering the muffler.
--omgomg, I agree with your statement about being "purposely engineered," concluding now that this is exactly what Jaguar intended. Every factory power-added application I've had (supercharger or turbo) has run rich. Of course, as you say, it's also part of those sweet exhaust pops and crackles.
--Torrid, I've come 180 on this to your way of thinking. Though there is water (and rust) in any exhaust system, Jaguar has purposely designed these inlet clamps to release excessive water. (Perhaps a way to avoid excessive moisture from entering/interfering with the Active Exhaust bypass valves?)
--mm767cap, ditto. I love those droplets now, heh.
Again, thanks for all your comments. Much appreciated. Now where did I put my old drip pan?
Just to respond to some of your thoughts--
--Alexg, you reminded me that very few things in life are truly important. Black sooty exhaust isn't one of them.
--Philipintexas, the droppings happen immediately at cold start-up. Yes, the car runs rich, especially with the supercharger. Need to stay rich on boost to avoid detonation and other bad things. I purposely ran aggressively rich fuel maps on some of my turbo cars to ensure safety on the top-end.
--vic55, you're right. The soot will continue.
--Mulmur, just to clarify, those sooty droplets I described are not coming out of the tailpipes; they are dripping from the clamped connections of both inlet pipes just prior to entering the muffler.
--omgomg, I agree with your statement about being "purposely engineered," concluding now that this is exactly what Jaguar intended. Every factory power-added application I've had (supercharger or turbo) has run rich. Of course, as you say, it's also part of those sweet exhaust pops and crackles.
--Torrid, I've come 180 on this to your way of thinking. Though there is water (and rust) in any exhaust system, Jaguar has purposely designed these inlet clamps to release excessive water. (Perhaps a way to avoid excessive moisture from entering/interfering with the Active Exhaust bypass valves?)
--mm767cap, ditto. I love those droplets now, heh.
Again, thanks for all your comments. Much appreciated. Now where did I put my old drip pan?
#17
More than just running rich, this thread has this link:
https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/f...elight-124419/
2014 Jaguar F-Type is calibrated for sonic delight - SAE International
Something along the lines of actual fuel getting out the valves on the exhaust stroke, and combustion in the pipes, or at least incomplete combustion in the cylinder (which is basically the same thing).
My friend is very curious to see how long the cats last on the exhaust - hopefully at least through warranty.
https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/f...elight-124419/
2014 Jaguar F-Type is calibrated for sonic delight - SAE International
Jaguar engineers achieved this by defying convention. "Usually you’d cut the fuel to the cylinders, when the driver lifts off the accelerator," explained Andrew Lowis, the Gasoline Calibration Manager for the car. "We are delaying the point when we do that and igniting later than we might in normal circumstances. It produces a controlled misfire."
My friend is very curious to see how long the cats last on the exhaust - hopefully at least through warranty.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
FS[NorthEast]: HOT Black/Black '07 S-Type R w/55k miles for sale!
08Z06
PRIVATE For Sale / Trade or Buy Classifieds
2
10-24-2015 05:46 PM
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)