S-Type / S type R Supercharged V8 ( X200 ) 1999 - 2008 2001 - 2009
Sponsored by:
Sponsored by:

2002 s type broken Lug

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
  #21  
Old 11-30-2013 | 03:33 AM
Richard Moss's Avatar
Senior Member
Joined: Jun 2013
Posts: 158
Likes: 32
From: Abu Dhabi
Default

The remaining surface there is reasonably flat - it might be worth trying to drill through the remaining part of the wheelnut (avoiding the stud and wheel) and trying to split it to release the grip.
 
  #22  
Old 11-30-2013 | 10:30 AM
clubairth1's Avatar
Veteran Member
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 9,717
Likes: 2,521
From: home
Default

Yes I have read that too?? And not just from Jaguar.

I still use a very small amount of anti-seize on the threads but that does affect the torque reading.

I just can't assemble things dry.
.
.
.
 
  #23  
Old 11-30-2013 | 03:42 PM
kr98664's Avatar
Veteran Member
Joined: Oct 2012
Posts: 4,510
Likes: 2,107
From: Oregon
Default

Originally Posted by Richard Moss
The remaining surface there is reasonably flat - it might be worth trying to drill through the remaining part of the wheelnut (avoiding the stud and wheel) and trying to split it to release the grip.
What a great suggestion. To make it easier to drill, make a little guide block. Find a shallow nut with the same threads. Heat it red hot with a torch and then let it cool slowly. Now that it's annealed, you can clamp it in a drill press and drill a guide hole (parallel to the stud). Run this nut down the threads on the stud, and now you can drill directly into the remainder of the broken lug nut without worrying the bit will walk off.

If you carefully calculate the amount the drill bit sticks out past your homemade guide block (Use a short piece of brass tube as a drill stop), you can drill almost entirely through the broken piece without going into the wheel itself. With the broken piece weakened by drilling, you should be able to break it free with a few quick blows from a small cold chisel.
 
The following users liked this post:
Jumpin' Jag Flash (12-02-2013)
  #24  
Old 12-04-2013 | 01:56 AM
kr98664's Avatar
Veteran Member
Joined: Oct 2012
Posts: 4,510
Likes: 2,107
From: Oregon
Default

Originally Posted by kr98664
To make it easier to drill, make a little guide block. Find a shallow nut with the same threads. Heat it red hot with a torch and then let it cool slowly. Now that it's annealed...
Any progress to report? When I suggested how to make a guide block for drilling, my brain clutch must have been slipping. Rather than annealing and drilling through a nut, which will still be some tough material, you could make a guide block from a small chunk of mild steel or other easily workable material. It wouldn't even have to be threaded where it fits over the wheel stud. The hole would just have to fit over the threads without too much slop, that's all.

Hope this helps.
 
  #25  
Old 12-04-2013 | 07:37 AM
2002jeff's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Member
Joined: Nov 2013
Posts: 39
Likes: 3
From: ft lauderdale
Default

let me just say how much I love this Blog. you guys are great. WELL.....I did get the Erwin bolt remover kit, but it did not fit. the remaining nut was too big. so I thought I would use my chisel to break loose the rest of the nut so I could use the bolt/nut remover kit. not the right choice. instead of breaking the remainder free all I did was mash it around. the metal is way to hard for a that. now the drilling it out is a good idea but now I might have really messed up the threads. so now no laughing but I will show what it looks like now. also I got a bit mad that my idea was not working so... as most of us do. I started hitting it harder....hay Im a guy. I also figured the lug nut was cracked at the last installation, because it broke free with very little effort. love the idea of making a jig for drilling the LUG but will try to drill the reaming of the nut first. so many other items on this car were such an easy fix with the vast knowledge of this board I guess I got a bit cocky and might have messed this up royally.
 
Attached Thumbnails 2002 s type   broken Lug-imag0897_1.jpg   2002 s type   broken Lug-imag0895.jpg  
  #26  
Old 12-04-2013 | 07:40 AM
2002jeff's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Member
Joined: Nov 2013
Posts: 39
Likes: 3
From: ft lauderdale
Default

sandy thanks, what a great idea. wish I had this before I stared with my idea. see pics
 
  #27  
Old 12-04-2013 | 08:14 AM
police666's Avatar
Veteran Member
Joined: Nov 2011
Posts: 1,154
Likes: 221
From: Liverpool, U.K.
Default

I know it's no laughing matter, but, I lol. Sorry.
 
  #28  
Old 12-04-2013 | 01:27 PM
2002jeff's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Member
Joined: Nov 2013
Posts: 39
Likes: 3
From: ft lauderdale
Default

its ok I deserve it
 
  #29  
Old 12-04-2013 | 02:24 PM
phaelax's Avatar
Senior Member
Joined: Feb 2009
Posts: 453
Likes: 19
From: Columbus, OH
Default

I feel your pain. Bent my rim in an enormous pot hole on the highway the night before I had to leave for 8 months. Couldn't get the donut on because a nut was seized on. Great way to spend my last night home. Anyway, even hammering on a one of those special sockets with the teeth to really eat into it for removal did not work, it just stripped more (POS lugnuts!) Eventually, after I returned home, I had it drilled out through the stud.
 
  #30  
Old 12-04-2013 | 04:11 PM
kr98664's Avatar
Veteran Member
Joined: Oct 2012
Posts: 4,510
Likes: 2,107
From: Oregon
Default

Okay, I've got another idea. Let's call this one Plan B. Find a deepwell 3/8" drive socket that fits over the stud. Using a grinder, form some teeth on the end of the socket. Angle the teeth to dig in when rotating counterclockwise, sort of like a hole saw in reverse.

Next, get one of these, known in aviation as a screw knocker:

"Old Man" Screw Knocker/Remover Size: 8"

That is a special tool that fits into a pneumatic air hammer or rivet gun. If you don't have an air hammer, even a cheap one will do. The air hammer will drive the teeth (on the end of the socket) into the remains of the nut and hopefully get a half-decent grip. While applying impact force with the air hammer, turn the handle on the tool. You may need to use a short cheater bar. A helper may come in handy, too.

The impact force from the air hammer, pounding directly on the broken nut, will hopefully vibrate it loose. In aviation circles (my day job), we use a screw knocker to break stubborn fasteners loose. They work almost every time, even on screw heads that look totally stripped out. You would be amazed at what they can do. It would definitely be worth a try as long as you can modify a deepwell socket to give it some teeth on the end.
 
  #31  
Old 12-04-2013 | 05:10 PM
tbird6's Avatar
Veteran Member
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 3,899
Likes: 802
From: Home
Default

If you are in this deep, here is what I would do.

Get a hole saw that is close to the OD of the wheel stud. Center punch the wheel stud so the center bit of the hole saw does not walk. Then carefully cut the lug nut off the stud. The remaining thin shell of metal still around the wheel stud will be easier to peel off and you will have some room to work. I hope you don’t damage the rim too badly.

It will damage the stud but after seeing your pictures I would plan on replacing it after you get the wheel off anyway.

This can be a real SOB to repair so you are not doing anything wrong. It's just hard to fix!
.
.
.
 
The following users liked this post:
Norri (12-04-2013)
  #32  
Old 12-04-2013 | 07:16 PM
kr98664's Avatar
Veteran Member
Joined: Oct 2012
Posts: 4,510
Likes: 2,107
From: Oregon
Default

If you are in this deep, here is what I would do.
Get a hole saw that is close to the OD of the wheel stud. Center punch the wheel stud so the center bit of the hole saw does not walk.
.
Uff Da! Wish I had thought of this idea. As far as centering the hole saw over the stud, as long as the hole saw's inside diameter is close to the stud's outside diameter, you could just remove the pilot bit.

Assuming the wheel has some minor damage now, don't despair. Much to my surprise, the nice folks at Coventry included a full size spare. Use the damaged rim as your spare, and it should be just fine for limited use if ever needed.
 
  #33  
Old 12-04-2013 | 08:08 PM
Mikey's Avatar
Joined: Oct 2009
Posts: 11,058
Likes: 2,266
From: Perth Ontario Canada
Default

As an idea, loosen the other lugnuts by a turn or two and move the car back and forth at a slow speed. This may put enough load on the broken nut to loosen it.
 
  #34  
Old 12-05-2013 | 06:55 AM
2002jeff's Avatar
Thread Starter
|
Member
Joined: Nov 2013
Posts: 39
Likes: 3
From: ft lauderdale
Default

thanks guys. I cant say it enough how much I appreciate this blog and its fellow bloggers. as you can see in this pic what im trying to get through is the two locking washers that are still on the core of the Lug Nut. once off I can get the bolt remover on the reaming core and hopefully get it off. I will try some of the ideas (all are great, I don't have a full shop) so im limited to basic stuff.


Keep you posted and I hope to return in victory.


also good call on the full size spare in the trunk, so I can get a bit aggressive on the rim and I have a 100% perfect on in the trunk to use.


2002jeff
 
Attached Thumbnails 2002 s type   broken Lug-imag0857.jpg  
  #35  
Old 12-05-2013 | 07:08 AM
abonano's Avatar
Joined: Mar 2012
Posts: 4,753
Likes: 1,429
From: Hazlet Township, NJ
Default

Originally Posted by 2002jeff
let me just say how much I love this Blog. you guys are great. WELL.....I did get the Erwin bolt remover kit, but it did not fit. the remaining nut was too big. so I thought I would use my chisel to break loose the rest of the nut so I could use the bolt/nut remover kit. not the right choice. instead of breaking the remainder free all I did was mash it around. the metal is way to hard for a that. now the drilling it out is a good idea but now I might have really messed up the threads. so now no laughing but I will show what it looks like now. also I got a bit mad that my idea was not working so... as most of us do. I started hitting it harder....hay Im a guy. I also figured the lug nut was cracked at the last installation, because it broke free with very little effort. love the idea of making a jig for drilling the LUG but will try to drill the reaming of the nut first. so many other items on this car were such an easy fix with the vast knowledge of this board I guess I got a bit cocky and might have messed this up royally.
Ouch to the rim. I had the dreaded lock nut scenario - I was able to hammer in a sacrificial 19 mm - 6 point socket to get the rounded lock nut off w/o damaging my rim - but you have nothing to work with here... ugh!

Needless to say I have the 1 piece units on the wheels now...
 
  #36  
Old 12-05-2013 | 08:08 AM
JagV8's Avatar
Veteran Member
Joined: May 2009
Posts: 26,836
Likes: 4,573
From: Yorkshire, England
Default

Even the 1-piece lug nuts won't save you from the "mechanics" over here who torque things so high with their air guns. People get snapped studs!! Needs to be illegal, frankly.

Only way is to know these dangerous idiots exist, then you know to make sure anyone fitting a wheel tightens to spec.
 
The following users liked this post:
Jumpin' Jag Flash (12-05-2013)
  #37  
Old 12-05-2013 | 11:15 AM
V40TC's Avatar
Member
Joined: May 2012
Posts: 50
Likes: 6
From: Somerset England
Default

Originally Posted by Davie

That was then and this is now. Between then and now, that's a different story!

With a matter of days before being pointed south and launched into the unknown, I was still running around 'fixing' stuff. New wiper blades for the front at a whopping £1.76p each and another trip the the breakers in search of a n/s/f washer jet, an o/s/f mirror assembly and a spare wheel. Washer jet sorted, mirror assembly remained elusive and spare wheel... well I kinda got lucky and happened across these,



Ok, so not exactly required but given they were shod with four matching Bridgestone Potenzas (rear are as new) all round and my original alloys were properlly scabby, plus the fact they wanted £40 for a single wheel / tyre, these made sense. If nothing else, I figured I could sell them on. Cue the wails for the "OMG! Part worns. You'll die" brigade. I also found one of those handy under boot storage trays. Job done.

Next, replace the worn o/s/f rack end that had been highlighted in the MoT. Wasn't critical but it was a bit wandery on the motorway so with 1,000+ ahead, for the want of £13.00 it made sense to replace it. It also made sense to chuck the wee man at Kerbside Motors £20 to fit in, which I'm glad a dig as he made short work of the seized track rod end and the mega tight inner streeing arm with some fancy tools. A further £20 to have the geometry checked and adjusted and we were cooking with gas.

Or not... I also asked him to remove the locking nuts a) they're **** b) who steals wheels these days and c) I didn't fancy fannying around at 3am, in the rain at the side of the M6 with a puncture. And that's where it all went wrong. Three came out no problem, the fourth - not a chance. 2hrs of power bats, air guns, impact drivers, swearing and even the proper RAC / AA approved tool and the nut was refusing to move.



Google suggested McGard do a drill out kit, in essence three sleeves with a progressively larger hole in the centre so you can drill out the locker whilst remaining central. Only issue, it was Saturday and I was leaving on the Monday. A mercy call went out and saw me armed with some insanely sharp drill bits and a man sized power drill. 2hrs later and I'd made a 2mm deep hole. I swore a lot and considered calling Enterprise. Final attempt, remove all the other nuts and drive the car in a circle hoping it'd a) stretch the bolt or b) distort the seat in the alloy and thus relieve some pressure. Did it work? Did it fu...

Dummy well and truly spat out the pram, final mercy call went out and it was off to see a mate of a mate who again had a crack with the pukka lock nut kit - ie the one that you leather a brass (?) stud down into the locker, thet then forms to the pattern and then in theory with a few smacks and an impact driver, job done. Always works, yet to have one that didn't come out. First for everything. I sukled some more.

Decision time, do we heat the bolt from the back but risk damaging the bearing and associated parts or simply admit defeat and keep drilling. I looked at the new wheels in the boot, looked at the scabby original alloy that was sat there, sneering at me...

Now, again those from an engineering / OCD / Daily Mail background, look away now...







Lock nut removal, the man's method. £25.00 and one wheel lighter, the four replacement alloys were on, one of the best original ones took up residence as a spare and with the tank filled it was M74 bound, next stop Bristol. 5hrs (ish) later and from there onto Devon. Couple of days doing best man duties then back to Bristol, quick visit to the city centre for old times sake and then it was aim north and back to base George and don't spare the horses.

Granted, it's now a sort of dark grey colour and the interior smells a bit iffy but I somewhat astounded to say it never once missed a beat. Compared to the old V70 diesel, it's infinitely more refined and comfortable and despite the guff-o-matic box, it seemingly returned 27mpg for the entire 1150 mile trip, which isn't that bad given it sat at a steady 80ish for the majority of the trip plus did a good few cross country miles into north Devon. Oil useage was nil, coolant useage was nil, AA useage was nil.

Few wee niggles to sort - rear 12v socket doesn't work so it was a constant battle to keep the DVD / phones charged,. Really need an o/s/f mirror assembly and the n/s/f headlight as filled with condensation for some reason. Nothing major though. It's now being drafted into daily commute / school run mode then it's back to Devon in three weeks again.

I'm actually quite attached to it now, so much so it's since earned it's place and thus has been named Helga... much like the previous five Volvos.







Well this on escalated quickly
 
Attached Thumbnails 2002 s type   broken Lug-dsc_3323_zps6d40b7ad.jpg   2002 s type   broken Lug-dsc_3327_zps564e88b3.jpg   2002 s type   broken Lug-dsc_3333_zpsf9d93b65.jpg   2002 s type   broken Lug-dsc_3335_zps0959ea27.jpg   2002 s type   broken Lug-dsc_3337_zps222b3905.jpg  

  #38  
Old 12-05-2013 | 11:31 AM
tbird6's Avatar
Veteran Member
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 3,899
Likes: 802
From: Home
Default

Thanks for that! It certainly was much worse than anything I have had to fix!!
.
.
.
 
  #39  
Old 12-05-2013 | 06:27 PM
Jumpin' Jag Flash's Avatar
Veteran Member
Joined: Mar 2013
Posts: 3,018
Likes: 182
From: Pawleys Island, SC USA (formerly from Tabernacle, NJ USA)
Default Not that familiar with wheel studs but...

...would it have been possible to grind the head of the locked stud off from behind?
 
  #40  
Old 12-06-2013 | 10:50 AM
tbird6's Avatar
Veteran Member
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 3,899
Likes: 802
From: Home
Default

No way to get to it.
.
.
.
 
The following users liked this post:
Jumpin' Jag Flash (12-06-2013)


Quick Reply: 2002 s type broken Lug



All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:24 PM.