"The Lurch" Theory
#43
Jon89 - quite. I've found poboyblues to be knowledgeable, so am certainly inclined to believe him. However, there's a gulf between what we know for sure, what we can measure and so on.
If the data is on GTR I'm probably willing to pay to join and read it. I object to paying without knowing what I'd be getting.
Anyone can go into a dealer and ask to have the newest TCM software. But how would you check the dealer properly did the reflash?
How many dealers would let you sit with their tech as the work was done so you could check the data?
I can read the "calibration" version (CVN as it's known in OBD) for PCM and TCM but I don't know what they should be. (I have an ELM lead and enough software to do this.)
(A similar gulf would apply if I had a BMW with ZF box.)
If the data is on GTR I'm probably willing to pay to join and read it. I object to paying without knowing what I'd be getting.
Anyone can go into a dealer and ask to have the newest TCM software. But how would you check the dealer properly did the reflash?
How many dealers would let you sit with their tech as the work was done so you could check the data?
I can read the "calibration" version (CVN as it's known in OBD) for PCM and TCM but I don't know what they should be. (I have an ELM lead and enough software to do this.)
(A similar gulf would apply if I had a BMW with ZF box.)
#44
#45
#46
Hi poboyblues,
Is the updated adaption procedure now considered a part of the normal maintenance schedule? It sounds fairly straightforward and quick. If not, I would think it would be a fairly reasonable service item similar to a wheel balancing or radiator service.
Thanks,
Mike
Is the updated adaption procedure now considered a part of the normal maintenance schedule? It sounds fairly straightforward and quick. If not, I would think it would be a fairly reasonable service item similar to a wheel balancing or radiator service.
Thanks,
Mike
If you're under warranty, it's free. If you are out of warranty, you pay.
#47
Unless there are other issues within the transmission, ie: leaks, burned fluid, worn clutches, etc. it fixes it. No laptop procedure, no permanent fix. I used to adapt those transmissions as posted above. Was only temporary. Believe it or not, doesn't matter to me.
#48
Thanks poboyblues,
I would have to say the service personnel I have dealt with are very professional and pleasant. When I took my Jaguar in for a problem with the expansion tank a while ago, they made every effort to address any issues I had with my S-Type. I brought up the issue I had with the differential and they resolved it fairly quickly. From my perspective, the effort Jaguar has expended towards customer satisfaction has certainly paid off. It may not mean much but please pass on my appreciation to the technicians in the trenches.
Mike
I would have to say the service personnel I have dealt with are very professional and pleasant. When I took my Jaguar in for a problem with the expansion tank a while ago, they made every effort to address any issues I had with my S-Type. I brought up the issue I had with the differential and they resolved it fairly quickly. From my perspective, the effort Jaguar has expended towards customer satisfaction has certainly paid off. It may not mean much but please pass on my appreciation to the technicians in the trenches.
Mike
#49
How many hours labor would I get charged for this to be done along with the fluid additive to heal the squeek ? Jaguar of GreatNeck has a labor charge of $125 an hour
Does this laptop procedure update the TCM or would that be a seperate job ?
I ask cause being my age married and expecting a kid, I cant afford to risk a transmission swap . Thanks and this wont go unapreciated
-Vee
#50
I can't honestly be accurate here, Vee. Some dealers charge differently, of course. I would expect at least 3 hours or so for the additive, TCM reflash, and adaptation procedure. The adaptation procedure alone takes quite some time as there are many adaptations to perform several times during the process. Also Jag recommends the adaptation procedure be done as a two man operation due to liability issues with driving with a live laptop. Can't drive and run a computer at the same time. This is the way we have to do it, so we do it.
#51
Thanks poboyblues,
I would have to say the service personnel I have dealt with are very professional and pleasant. When I took my Jaguar in for a problem with the expansion tank a while ago, they made every effort to address any issues I had with my S-Type. I brought up the issue I had with the differential and they resolved it fairly quickly. From my perspective, the effort Jaguar has expended towards customer satisfaction has certainly paid off. It may not mean much but please pass on my appreciation to the technicians in the trenches.
Mike
I would have to say the service personnel I have dealt with are very professional and pleasant. When I took my Jaguar in for a problem with the expansion tank a while ago, they made every effort to address any issues I had with my S-Type. I brought up the issue I had with the differential and they resolved it fairly quickly. From my perspective, the effort Jaguar has expended towards customer satisfaction has certainly paid off. It may not mean much but please pass on my appreciation to the technicians in the trenches.
Mike
#53
Jon89 - quite. I've found poboyblues to be knowledgeable, so am certainly inclined to believe him. However, there's a gulf between what we know for sure, what we can measure and so on.
If the data is on GTR I'm probably willing to pay to join and read it. I object to paying without knowing what I'd be getting.
Anyone can go into a dealer and ask to have the newest TCM software. But how would you check the dealer properly did the reflash?
How many dealers would let you sit with their tech as the work was done so you could check the data?
I can read the "calibration" version (CVN as it's known in OBD) for PCM and TCM but I don't know what they should be. (I have an ELM lead and enough software to do this.)
(A similar gulf would apply if I had a BMW with ZF box.)
If the data is on GTR I'm probably willing to pay to join and read it. I object to paying without knowing what I'd be getting.
Anyone can go into a dealer and ask to have the newest TCM software. But how would you check the dealer properly did the reflash?
How many dealers would let you sit with their tech as the work was done so you could check the data?
I can read the "calibration" version (CVN as it's known in OBD) for PCM and TCM but I don't know what they should be. (I have an ELM lead and enough software to do this.)
(A similar gulf would apply if I had a BMW with ZF box.)
Oh, I just became a senior member, and yet I know very little about Jaguars......
#55
That was a bit terse, sorry.
government and others set goals:
lower emissions
better fuel efficiency
better braking
comfort (a/c etc)
audio etc
and all the rest
so we got broadband-connected multi-computer vehicles
S-Type has 4 different buses (aka busses) (ISO 9141, SCP/PWM, CAN, D2B) and a lot of modules each with complex electronics
trying to mix fuel with air and burn it
a fairly small number of codes (DTCs) are reported via OBD
all the other errors might be reported in who knows what ways
government and others set goals:
lower emissions
better fuel efficiency
better braking
comfort (a/c etc)
audio etc
and all the rest
so we got broadband-connected multi-computer vehicles
S-Type has 4 different buses (aka busses) (ISO 9141, SCP/PWM, CAN, D2B) and a lot of modules each with complex electronics
trying to mix fuel with air and burn it
a fairly small number of codes (DTCs) are reported via OBD
all the other errors might be reported in who knows what ways
#56
#57
#58
Lurch latest TSB?
I can't honestly be accurate here, Vee. Some dealers charge differently, of course. I would expect at least 3 hours or so for the additive, TCM reflash, and adaptation procedure. The adaptation procedure alone takes quite some time as there are many adaptations to perform several times during the process. Also Jag recommends the adaptation procedure be done as a two man operation due to liability issues with driving with a live laptop. Can't drive and run a computer at the same time. This is the way we have to do it, so we do it.
Question: Do you have the TSB number for this procedure?
My dealer is not aware of the lurch Theory (or so they claim)
I have TSB S307-17 to show them but you state that is now obsolete.
That is why I would love to have the number of the latest TSB if there is one,
Thanks for helping on here it is much appreciated.
#59
Lurch Theory Question
I got the reprogramming of the TCM and they did the adaptive work also. I will drive according to suggestions for the next 200 miles and see what happens and report back. I do notice right away there is more pep at start-up, the shifting takes place at a different rpm and the gas mileage appears up about 10%. We will see if it holds.
Last edited by jazzwineman; 09-30-2009 at 09:37 PM.