4.2 vs 5.0 (2009 vs 2010)
#21
#22
Isn't the 5.0L rated higher for MPG than the 4.2L? I know the 5.0L SC was rated higher than the 4.2L SC. I have noticed that the 2012 XF 5.0L (NA) loaner I was driving around gets about the same gas mileage as my 2009 4.2L Supercharged which doesn't line up with the ratings I've seen.
After driving the 2012 XF 5.0L for a while I do really like the 2012 changes. All the small annoying issues the dealer can't find or fix on my 2009 are not present on the 2012. I love the front end and headlights. The nav/entertainment system has really grown on me. The USB sticks that don't work in my 09 work fine in the 2012 plus it plays all my Top Gear videos on the screen.
If someone was looking at a 2009 XF (NA or SC) vs. a 2012 XF 5.0L (NA) I'd say go with the 2012. Even though I really love my 2009 SC I'm sorry to say that the 2012 (overall) edges it out. Of course price couldn't be a factor because ~$25k more for a 2012 is a good chunk of change.
After driving the 2012 XF 5.0L for a while I do really like the 2012 changes. All the small annoying issues the dealer can't find or fix on my 2009 are not present on the 2012. I love the front end and headlights. The nav/entertainment system has really grown on me. The USB sticks that don't work in my 09 work fine in the 2012 plus it plays all my Top Gear videos on the screen.
If someone was looking at a 2009 XF (NA or SC) vs. a 2012 XF 5.0L (NA) I'd say go with the 2012. Even though I really love my 2009 SC I'm sorry to say that the 2012 (overall) edges it out. Of course price couldn't be a factor because ~$25k more for a 2012 is a good chunk of change.
#24
I feel the same way going from the SC to the NA versions. When I punch it on the highway and the car downshifts the supercharger really makes this car scream. I've driven a few XF 5.0 loaners and while they are no doubt quick my 4.2L SC is still faster, more responsive, stops better, sounds better, has better steering feedback, etc. I've driven both for a decent amount of time and it comes from experience not magazine numbers.
Yes, the XF 5.0 is significantly stouter than my 4.2; however, I will take a 09' 4.2L SC over the 5.0 just for the "fun factor"....pray for no more traffic tickets.
#25
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
philwarner
XJ XJ6 / XJ8 / XJR ( X350 & X358 )
5
10-02-2015 11:23 AM
bydand
XF and XFR ( X250 )
8
09-28-2015 09:47 AM
060, 2009, 2010, 2011, 42, 50, difference, displacement, gto, increasing, jaguar, slower, supercharged, time, xf
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)