Timing chain - Dealership mechanic's observations
#1
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I have a 2012 XF 5.0L with 55K miles. Things have been great other than a water pump, some coolant system related plastic pipes/ hoses changed a while back. Been maintained at Jaguar dealership with regular 5k Oil changes.
Went for an oil change at the dealership. Since timing chain has been a problem area for these cars as miles go up, requested them to have a look at/ listen in. They didn't do any specific diagnostics work as there will be additional charges for it but as part of the multi point inspection gave their findings. As per the mechanic "Upon removing oil cap and grabbing chain it has small movement. Estimates quarter to half inch loose"
How bad these can get? My service adviser said it can go without any issues for another 5 years or it can break on your way home. I think he was trying to comfort me
.
Should I be taking second opinion from someone? Spending a ton of money at dealership is out of question. Since I am not even doing an oil change myself, you can imagine how mechanically inclined I am to work on these.
What are my options?
Went for an oil change at the dealership. Since timing chain has been a problem area for these cars as miles go up, requested them to have a look at/ listen in. They didn't do any specific diagnostics work as there will be additional charges for it but as part of the multi point inspection gave their findings. As per the mechanic "Upon removing oil cap and grabbing chain it has small movement. Estimates quarter to half inch loose"
How bad these can get? My service adviser said it can go without any issues for another 5 years or it can break on your way home. I think he was trying to comfort me
![Smile](https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/images/smilies/smile.gif)
Should I be taking second opinion from someone? Spending a ton of money at dealership is out of question. Since I am not even doing an oil change myself, you can imagine how mechanically inclined I am to work on these.
![Icon Cry](https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/images/smilies/icon_cry.gif)
Last edited by aparanschumi; 11-14-2020 at 02:16 PM.
#2
Join Date: Jan 2012
Location: Newport Beach, California
Posts: 5,664
Received 2,670 Likes
on
1,834 Posts
#3
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I’m gonna call BS on this. Never worked on the 5.0 L but I seriously doubt you can open up the oil filler cap and move a camshaft or touch the timing chain to determine if the timing chain is loose.
EDIT- maybe im wrong. I just pulled up a picture of the 5.0 L engine and the oil filler cap is up in front by the chain so maybe it’s possible. So ignore my previous statement
EDIT- maybe im wrong. I just pulled up a picture of the 5.0 L engine and the oil filler cap is up in front by the chain so maybe it’s possible. So ignore my previous statement
Last edited by Aarcuda; 11-14-2020 at 01:56 PM.
#4
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
The Jaguar Land Rover V8 5.0 engine has a design flaw in the timing chain tensioners. This defect was fixed in 2012-2013 but the 5.0 V8 engines manufactured until then (including yours) will need to be repaired within approximately 100,000 miles. Your options are:
1.-Wait for the engine to start making ticking/ratling noises due to the timing chain being too loose. Noises may appear after cold starting or after warm start, mine for example made more noise after warm start.
2.- Since the defect of the tensioners is already noticeable when pressing the chain through the oil cap (loose chain), you could take the car to an official dealer or a good mechanic to change everything: chains, tensioners, guides and sprockets. This option is very expensive, especially at an official dealer.
3.- Take the car to a good mechanic or official dealer and tell him that you want to change only the tensioners and the chain guides.using the official zip tie method. This is the option that I chose for my car and is obviously much cheaper, I did it myself and now the engine runs perfect and very smooth. Attached the official Jaguar pdf file in which the whole process is explained step by step.
1.-Wait for the engine to start making ticking/ratling noises due to the timing chain being too loose. Noises may appear after cold starting or after warm start, mine for example made more noise after warm start.
2.- Since the defect of the tensioners is already noticeable when pressing the chain through the oil cap (loose chain), you could take the car to an official dealer or a good mechanic to change everything: chains, tensioners, guides and sprockets. This option is very expensive, especially at an official dealer.
3.- Take the car to a good mechanic or official dealer and tell him that you want to change only the tensioners and the chain guides.using the official zip tie method. This is the option that I chose for my car and is obviously much cheaper, I did it myself and now the engine runs perfect and very smooth. Attached the official Jaguar pdf file in which the whole process is explained step by step.
Last edited by xfportfolio; 11-14-2020 at 06:18 PM.
The following users liked this post:
TXFireblade (11-14-2020)
#5
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Thanks xfportfolio, I see the procedure requires the removal of the engine mount on the left side (as you look at the engine from the front of the car). Was that actually necessary? I also see that only the tensioned chain guides are replaced. Did you also replace the fixed sides?
Thanks in advance.
Thanks in advance.
Last edited by TXFireblade; 11-14-2020 at 09:48 PM.
#6
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Good question and no, it is not necessary to remove the engine mount and the fuel lines, I don't know the reason why they say you have to do it but I skipped that part.
I only changed the hydraulic tensioners and the guide/blade on which the tensioner affects, because if you remove the fixed guide there is a risk for the chain to jump. I had some doubts about how to mount the tensioners but finally with the help of Davetibbs in this forum I managed to adjust them correctly. This is the forum post
I only changed the hydraulic tensioners and the guide/blade on which the tensioner affects, because if you remove the fixed guide there is a risk for the chain to jump. I had some doubts about how to mount the tensioners but finally with the help of Davetibbs in this forum I managed to adjust them correctly. This is the forum post
The following users liked this post:
TXFireblade (11-15-2020)
#7
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
The Jaguar Land Rover V8 5.0 engine has a design flaw in the timing chain tensioners. This defect was fixed in 2012-2013 but the 5.0 V8 engines manufactured until then (including yours) will need to be repaired within approximately 100,000 miles. Your options are:
1.-Wait for the engine to start making ticking/ratling noises due to the timing chain being too loose. Noises may appear after cold starting or after warm start, mine for example made more noise after warm start.
2.- Since the defect of the tensioners is already noticeable when pressing the chain through the oil cap (loose chain), you could take the car to an official dealer or a good mechanic to change everything: chains, tensioners, guides and sprockets. This option is very expensive, especially at an official dealer.
3.- Take the car to a good mechanic or official dealer and tell him that you want to change only the tensioners and the chain guides.using the official zip tie method. This is the option that I chose for my car and is obviously much cheaper, I did it myself and now the engine runs perfect and very smooth. Attached the official Jaguar pdf file in which the whole process is explained step by step.
1.-Wait for the engine to start making ticking/ratling noises due to the timing chain being too loose. Noises may appear after cold starting or after warm start, mine for example made more noise after warm start.
2.- Since the defect of the tensioners is already noticeable when pressing the chain through the oil cap (loose chain), you could take the car to an official dealer or a good mechanic to change everything: chains, tensioners, guides and sprockets. This option is very expensive, especially at an official dealer.
3.- Take the car to a good mechanic or official dealer and tell him that you want to change only the tensioners and the chain guides.using the official zip tie method. This is the option that I chose for my car and is obviously much cheaper, I did it myself and now the engine runs perfect and very smooth. Attached the official Jaguar pdf file in which the whole process is explained step by step.
Regarding option 2, Dealer already gave me a quote for changing everything $4k for labor and $5k for parts Total of $9k
![Icon Blah](https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/images/smilies/icon_blah.gif)
Trending Topics
#8
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Well, I spent in parts about 400 british pounds from lrparts.net + shiping to Spain (£20). Land Rover parts are cheaper and exactly the same.
Regarding labor I don´t know, you should ask the dealer for a quote
Regarding labor I don´t know, you should ask the dealer for a quote
#9
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Queen and Country
XK / XKR ( X150 )
112
02-17-2023 02:34 PM
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)