Seeking advice on the quietest 351
#41
I don't care for noise either and it is a compromise but there is a tire made just for that?
Have you looked at the ContiSilent line from Continental?
Quiet Tire
I guess everyone gonna release a foam tire?
Here is Michelin's version. Michelin® Acoustic Technology Tires.
Foam Filled Tire
Oops! Sorry you already mentioned the Michelin version up thread. Did you try them?
Same idea they have an internal layer of foam attached to the tread.
.
.
.
Have you looked at the ContiSilent line from Continental?
Quiet Tire
I guess everyone gonna release a foam tire?
Here is Michelin's version. Michelin® Acoustic Technology Tires.
Foam Filled Tire
Oops! Sorry you already mentioned the Michelin version up thread. Did you try them?
Same idea they have an internal layer of foam attached to the tread.
.
.
.
Last edited by clubairth1; 05-15-2023 at 01:39 PM.
The following users liked this post:
QP7 (05-15-2023)
#42
I don't care for noise either and it is a compromise but there is a tire made just for that?
Have you looked at the ContiSilent line?
Quiet Tire
.
.
.
Have you looked at the ContiSilent line?
Quiet Tire
.
.
.
Can we get it in the right size? 245 45 19 - 275 40 19.
Last edited by QP7; 05-15-2023 at 01:38 PM.
#43
Response from another old guy
Thank you for all the replies. appreciated. Very good remiinder about the dynamat also - thank you. I too thought they never made a non supercharged V6, but the cars I am looking at are in the far east and the seller claims (probably ignorantly that his is not SC and V6). And I appreciate all the comments about get the best MY year you can and the best model. Having come from the MB W140 model, I know all too well how early model years can be, shall we say, explosively painful. It seems the X351 is much better that many recent MB's (eg W220 - nightmare reliability) and also better right from the get go vs the W140. The "interesting" part is the country I am in, in has NO Jaguar dealer. Yes you heard that right. None. Now before you all think I am crazy, the (so called) MB dealer here is worse than useless anyway. When I bought a 25,000 mile MB wagon they refused to work on it at al (much to my shock)l because it was in the 00's. . So if I do get one of the X351 cars I am looking at I will not do so until I have found a skilled Jaguar independent mechanic locally here. I have heard there is one (or two)... I appreciate the comments that he V6 is quieter. Thank you. As for sticking with the Merc, I still have a V12 W140 in USA, so need to feel young again which given my very advanced years, means I may well be making the switch and defecting to X351. Any advice on what can (or often) go wrong or tends not to, in the 2013 MY suspension would be appreciated. Thanks all...
The following users liked this post:
QP7 (06-04-2023)
#44
Whatever you do. Don’t buy a Jaguar F-Type if you are looking for a quiet ride. I traded I my XJ due to being 12 years old / 150,000 miles and Cosmetically worn out. Wife raised 3 kids in it with ivory interior. Purchased a F-Type and the interior road noise is incredibly LOUD. I really miss the XJ.
#45
Join Date: Feb 2014
Location: Adelaide, South Australia
Posts: 8,527
Received 3,266 Likes
on
2,410 Posts
Whatever you do. Don’t buy a Jaguar F-Type if you are looking for a quiet ride. I traded I my XJ due to being 12 years old / 150,000 miles and Cosmetically worn out. Wife raised 3 kids in it with ivory interior. Purchased a F-Type and the interior road noise is incredibly LOUD. I really miss the XJ.
I put the increased noise down to JLR skimping on the insulation in the F-Type, it's already a bit of a fat pig so I think they decided to save some weight by reducing the insulation down to the bare minimum. Seems to me that most of the noise comes in through the wheel wells especially the rears and there is stuff all insulation in those wheel wells. I have looked into applying spray on insulation in the wheel wells but couldn't find anything suitable, maybe one day I will experiment with sound deadening panels such as Dynamat up under the wheel well liners, if that is even possible. My research indicates that insulation such as Dynamat is meant to be applied in the cabin under the trim but I am loathe to rip interior trim panels off for fear of damaging the clips or the panels and ending up with poor fitting and/or rattly panels.
#46
#47
On my XF, I ditched the 19's and went down to 18's, PLUS I chose a tire size slightly bigger overall diameter than the original 19" tires. Overall I got an extra 3/4 inch of sidewall. Day and night difference! Major improvement. I'm sure the XJ has a little leeway too. But what I did, here we have some "used tire" stores on the wrong side of town and for like $50 you can test-drive a tire before ordering $900+ worth of new tires. Just call around and find the tire/size you are considering and have it mounted on one wheel. Make sure it doesn't look like its going to rub on the left front and then carefully drive it round a bit, making more and more extreme turns and inclines. If it doesn't rub, move it to the right front and do the same. Same with the rear, tho you probably only need to test one side.
Crazy thing is that I downsized my XF to coincidentally the same size tire that comes stock on a 2023 Mustang GT. This wheel vanity-sizing fad needs to end because the roads we drive on are only getting worse, not better. Seriously its one of the reasons new car buyers are gravitating to SUVs now. SUVs are also coming with 19 and 20 inch wheels, much larger than really needed, but they have greater suspension travel and taller aspect ratio tires to better handle the bad roads.
Crazy thing is that I downsized my XF to coincidentally the same size tire that comes stock on a 2023 Mustang GT. This wheel vanity-sizing fad needs to end because the roads we drive on are only getting worse, not better. Seriously its one of the reasons new car buyers are gravitating to SUVs now. SUVs are also coming with 19 and 20 inch wheels, much larger than really needed, but they have greater suspension travel and taller aspect ratio tires to better handle the bad roads.
The following users liked this post:
QP7 (06-08-2023)
#48
I believe the Xj S is much quieter than the F type !!! Showing my age here... It does seem for many years manufacturers went mad thinking we want low profile tires? Does anyone on here drive like Senna or Prost or Verstappen? Didn't think so... so why do we want 35 or 45 profile bone crushing rides on delapidated roads. It's insane.. If my X351 cant become quiet I will happily / sadly sell and go back in time to 16" wheeled W140 Merc from the late 1990's (if I can find one that is one owner, immaculate etc.). Love the way the Jag looks but if it ends up being too loud, 16" wheels and 65 profiles on a double glazed Benz here I come. Hopefully not !
#49
The following users liked this post:
QP7 (06-09-2023)
#50
In fact its marketing and everybody who races know that it´s totally opposite: Higher profile tyre gives more grip. (ofcourse the suspension will need to be build up for the race car with combination of the vehicle and tyre, so just swapping tyres don´t make the trick) F1 cars went from 13" to 18" rim size because FIA want to tame the speed for safety.
A friend of mine is an automotive journalist. He developed a theory for why there is so much attention to "performance" over comfort. He noted that every time he gets invited to the launch of a new model car, they always have it at a race track. Doesn't matter if the new model is a boring grocery getter SUV, they still have a launch party at a race track. He thinks it's directly targeted at HIM. They make sure he gets the most exciting experience possible in hopes that he will write a glowing review. But of course he's going to write about the smooth ride because the race track is as smooth as it gets. He's also going to write about how well it handles, because they've arranged for him to drive it through a slalom or a few chicanes. He says he'd rather have the press car to drive around town for a week so that he could write about how practical it is to live with, but he's not one their A-list journalists so those opportunities come all too infrequent. He said that manufacturers also know that the average new car test drive is only about 10 minutes and they have to stimulate rather than sedate in order to make the sale. Its only after you've already committed and driven it for a week that you realize that you are miserable. Oh but wait: that means you have to trade it back in at a significant loss and buy a different new car - WIN!
Last edited by pdupler; 06-08-2023 at 10:22 PM.
The following users liked this post:
QP7 (06-09-2023)
#51
Brake disc size is one big reason for the increase in wheel sizes. But 18" should be enough room to fully accommodate a large sedan. 19 might be needed for a large SUV but that's about it. 20inch on a passenger car is technically not necessary.
But wait: bigger wheels are more expensive, so these have to be better!
But wait: bigger wheels are more expensive, so these have to be better!
The following users liked this post:
QP7 (06-10-2023)
#52
OK, after several weeks very careful research and reading I have pretty much decided on which tires will make the 2013 XJL the quietest and with the best ride, while sticking with the 19 inch wheels. Tire rack has also been very helpful..., not just their test data but also key people there on their chat function, as some of them have actually test driven all of these tires..
Given everything while the Goodyear Assurance Comfort Drive and the Verdestein Quatrac Pro are very good, as is the Continental Extreme Contact DWS 06 Plus, the new Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3 is the quietest and best / softest riding, based on multiple detailed reviews. It means I will manipulate the tire size a bit more than standard, but I'm not overly worrried by that, but just want to know do you all think the following will fit on the rear: -
Rather than going with 275 40 19 on the rear, I will be going with 265 50 19. I am not concerned about speedometer error etc,; the only question I have is will that rire fit on the rear without rubbing? Any experience or knowledge as to if that wll fit on the rear on a 2013 XJL would be very much appreciated. Many thanks !
(I did look at 255 50 19 - which will also fit a 10 inch wheel but will likely not protect the sdewall as much).
****
For example this was one review by a customer on Tire raclk: -
"I previously had Bridgestone Turanza Quiettrack 245/45R20 on my 2016 Range Rover Evoque SE Premium and changing to these Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3 275/45R20 drastically changed the overall feel. My primary focuses were on ride noise and quality. Hence, at the time of purchase for the Bridgestones, they were ranked #1 for ride quietness and quality. However, they are no more. Over the several months that I have owned the Bridgestones, the ride gradually became harsher and noisier. By 5/32, I decided to move on to these Pirellis. Long-term review is yet to be determined but as of now, they are amazingly quiet and very soft over bumps. These provide confidence over light or heavy rain. Performance on ice/snow is not yet executed. I would sincerely recommend these Pirelli tires to anyone intentionally looking for outstanding ride quality and dimished tire noise. Thanks for taking the time to read my review."...
and later he said
Many others all write the same...
Given everything while the Goodyear Assurance Comfort Drive and the Verdestein Quatrac Pro are very good, as is the Continental Extreme Contact DWS 06 Plus, the new Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3 is the quietest and best / softest riding, based on multiple detailed reviews. It means I will manipulate the tire size a bit more than standard, but I'm not overly worrried by that, but just want to know do you all think the following will fit on the rear: -
Rather than going with 275 40 19 on the rear, I will be going with 265 50 19. I am not concerned about speedometer error etc,; the only question I have is will that rire fit on the rear without rubbing? Any experience or knowledge as to if that wll fit on the rear on a 2013 XJL would be very much appreciated. Many thanks !
(I did look at 255 50 19 - which will also fit a 10 inch wheel but will likely not protect the sdewall as much).
****
For example this was one review by a customer on Tire raclk: -
"I previously had Bridgestone Turanza Quiettrack 245/45R20 on my 2016 Range Rover Evoque SE Premium and changing to these Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3 275/45R20 drastically changed the overall feel. My primary focuses were on ride noise and quality. Hence, at the time of purchase for the Bridgestones, they were ranked #1 for ride quietness and quality. However, they are no more. Over the several months that I have owned the Bridgestones, the ride gradually became harsher and noisier. By 5/32, I decided to move on to these Pirellis. Long-term review is yet to be determined but as of now, they are amazingly quiet and very soft over bumps. These provide confidence over light or heavy rain. Performance on ice/snow is not yet executed. I would sincerely recommend these Pirelli tires to anyone intentionally looking for outstanding ride quality and dimished tire noise. Thanks for taking the time to read my review."...
and later he said
October 20, 2022
"Had it on for another 10+ months and they are fantastic. Really quiet and comfortable ride still holds! My impression of these has not changed - still, definitely recommend them to others!"Many others all write the same...
Last edited by QP7; 06-17-2023 at 10:34 AM.
#53
265/50-19 tires have a circumference of 92.5" vs. 86.9" of OE. Speedometer error is the least of your worries. Using tires of this size difference will cause the Stability Control to assume a problem.
You've been studying, dissecting and analyzing cabin noise of a non-existent car on this forum for 2½ months. If your new purchase has squeaks, rattles or wind noise, these will be far more disturbing than the difference between tire brands. Take delivery of the car, drive it for a while, evaluate its suitability for your needs, then consider modifying it. And before you ask for opinions, give us well-meaning members as much information as possible. We don't even know, for example, if you will be driving on snow-covered roads. How can anyone recommend a tire without this information?
You've been studying, dissecting and analyzing cabin noise of a non-existent car on this forum for 2½ months. If your new purchase has squeaks, rattles or wind noise, these will be far more disturbing than the difference between tire brands. Take delivery of the car, drive it for a while, evaluate its suitability for your needs, then consider modifying it. And before you ask for opinions, give us well-meaning members as much information as possible. We don't even know, for example, if you will be driving on snow-covered roads. How can anyone recommend a tire without this information?
#54
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Great Mills, MD
Posts: 14,452
Likes: 0
Received 3,929 Likes
on
3,225 Posts
Quietness, if you do decide to go with the 265/50R19's, your best choice of tires for the front are going to be a set of 245/55/R19's. This will have only a 0.7% error between the diameters of the tires. Because these tires are a little bit narrower than the factory tires, the odds of you having any rubbing should be minimized. BUt, you are looking at an overall larger diameter tire. So, really hard to say what you are going to experience. I would not expect too much rubbing if there is any at all. Granted, if you went with 235/55R19's, you would still have a 0.7% error, but in this case, the front tires would be spinning faster than the rears and also have a bit more clearance in the front, minimizing any chance of rubbing. So, no real difference on the transfer case if it is installed (do no remember if you were getting the V6 or the V8). If the car is RWD only, then all the better. Just note, with this difference, the ABS is more likely to kick in and give you some feedback when it kicks in. You drive sensibly, should be a very infrequent thing. You drive a little spiritedly, expect it to kick in every now and then.
The following users liked this post:
QP7 (06-18-2023)
#55
Quietness, if you do decide to go with the 265/50R19's, your best choice of tires for the front are going to be a set of 245/55/R19's. This will have only a 0.7% error between the diameters of the tires. Because these tires are a little bit narrower than the factory tires, the odds of you having any rubbing should be minimized. BUt, you are looking at an overall larger diameter tire. So, really hard to say what you are going to experience. I would not expect too much rubbing if there is any at all. Granted, if you went with 235/55R19's, you would still have a 0.7% error, but in this case, the front tires would be spinning faster than the rears and also have a bit more clearance in the front, minimizing any chance of rubbing. So, no real difference on the transfer case if it is installed (do no remember if you were getting the V6 or the V8). If the car is RWD only, then all the better. Just note, with this difference, the ABS is more likely to kick in and give you some feedback when it kicks in. You drive sensibly, should be a very infrequent thing. You drive a little spiritedly, expect it to kick in every now and then.
#56
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Great Mills, MD
Posts: 14,452
Likes: 0
Received 3,929 Likes
on
3,225 Posts
Quietness, I say go with the 245's and see what you have. Worst case, you have to get a new set of front tires because of excesssive rubbing. But, with easy driving, it shouldn't be that big of a deal as the amount of flex will be minimal. The differences are minimal except in the 1 dimension you are after which is sidewall height. So, stick with the 245's and see what you have. It will be atleast good information for others in the future should they consider something similar.
#57
Quietness, I say go with the 245's and see what you have. Worst case, you have to get a new set of front tires because of excesssive rubbing. But, with easy driving, it shouldn't be that big of a deal as the amount of flex will be minimal. The differences are minimal except in the 1 dimension you are after which is sidewall height. So, stick with the 245's and see what you have. It will be atleast good information for others in the future should they consider something similar.
#58
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Great Mills, MD
Posts: 14,452
Likes: 0
Received 3,929 Likes
on
3,225 Posts
Quietness, the 235's should have less issues than the 245's. The 235's are 10mm less in tread width. So, you are going to have 5mm more distance between the tire and the fender. Because you are running a larger diameter tire, it is going to potentially hit "sooner" because you are going to touch a spot inside the wheel well vice on the metal edge (if you used a 245 vice a 235). With the radical size difference you are looking at, it is hard to say where things are going to touch first, if they touch at all.
The following users liked this post:
QP7 (06-18-2023)
#59
Quietness, the 235's should have less issues than the 245's. The 235's are 10mm less in tread width. So, you are going to have 5mm more distance between the tire and the fender. Because you are running a larger diameter tire, it is going to potentially hit "sooner" because you are going to touch a spot inside the wheel well vice on the metal edge (if you used a 245 vice a 235). With the radical size difference you are looking at, it is hard to say where things are going to touch first, if they touch at all.
Last edited by QP7; 06-24-2023 at 12:21 PM.
#60
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Great Mills, MD
Posts: 14,452
Likes: 0
Received 3,929 Likes
on
3,225 Posts
Quietness, as long as you keep the errors between the front and rear tires, all the systems will be fine. The only problem s I have seen is going with a dramatically different tire diameter. But, that is not really possible on this car. So, get the tires you are after and be happy driving.
As for the rim widths, 9's up front and 10's in the back sounds right.
As for the rim widths, 9's up front and 10's in the back sounds right.
The following users liked this post:
QP7 (06-24-2023)