Eibach CATS or no CATS
#1
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I can find several postings on the internet that only Eibach air struts for the X350 do support CATS.
But I have not been able to find any Eibach factory brochure or technical documentation that does say that the strut does alter between soft and hard damper setting according to CATS head units signal.
The Eibach is considerably more expansive than other available air strut brands. The high price is on many forums explained as being justified by the CATS support feature.
The X350 airstrut has the B4 gas (oil+ gas) normal damper that is not adjustable. B6 is a nonadjustable sport damper.
So can anyone find Eibach published information on this matter?
But I have not been able to find any Eibach factory brochure or technical documentation that does say that the strut does alter between soft and hard damper setting according to CATS head units signal.
The Eibach is considerably more expansive than other available air strut brands. The high price is on many forums explained as being justified by the CATS support feature.
The X350 airstrut has the B4 gas (oil+ gas) normal damper that is not adjustable. B6 is a nonadjustable sport damper.
So can anyone find Eibach published information on this matter?
#3
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Beautiful Pilot Mountain NC
Posts: 656
Received 183 Likes
on
103 Posts
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
OEM is Bilstein
Last time I looked, Bilsteins were the only aftermarket CATS shocks available, and only in "comfort" (not "sport" for XJR). They were ~ $3,200 the set
Dealer shocks (Bilsteins) are stupid expensive (and I couldn't find "sport"). BTW, OEM "sport" shocks look the same, but have smaller (therefore, stiffer) airbag, and tuned dampers
Absolutely DO NOT buy "rebuilt" air shocks, or Chinese air shocks, or Chinese spring shocks, etc
For about $1,200, Arnott makes a good quality steel spring replacement set, which feel about right in an XJR (they're definitely stiffer than "comfort"). Includes CATS error defeat wiring, which will require removing the back seat to fiddle in. Ride height is about stock, with a v slight rake to front. Note that rear steel spring conversion is a compromise between ride height and rear load weight
Believe Arnott uses (German) Eibach steel springs in some of their products
Best suspension is all new OEM Bilstein, but I find Arnott to be completely acceptable. Issue is ride quality, not handling. Air will be subtly better, on any car designed for it...
Last time I looked, Bilsteins were the only aftermarket CATS shocks available, and only in "comfort" (not "sport" for XJR). They were ~ $3,200 the set
Dealer shocks (Bilsteins) are stupid expensive (and I couldn't find "sport"). BTW, OEM "sport" shocks look the same, but have smaller (therefore, stiffer) airbag, and tuned dampers
Absolutely DO NOT buy "rebuilt" air shocks, or Chinese air shocks, or Chinese spring shocks, etc
For about $1,200, Arnott makes a good quality steel spring replacement set, which feel about right in an XJR (they're definitely stiffer than "comfort"). Includes CATS error defeat wiring, which will require removing the back seat to fiddle in. Ride height is about stock, with a v slight rake to front. Note that rear steel spring conversion is a compromise between ride height and rear load weight
Believe Arnott uses (German) Eibach steel springs in some of their products
Best suspension is all new OEM Bilstein, but I find Arnott to be completely acceptable. Issue is ride quality, not handling. Air will be subtly better, on any car designed for it...
The following users liked this post:
pkoko (05-25-2022)
#4
#7
Trending Topics
#8
#9
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
[QUOTE=hisport;2528697]OEM is Bilstein
Last time I looked, Bilsteins were the only aftermarket CATS shocks available, and only in "comfort" (not "sport" for XJR). They were ~ $3,200 the set
Please stick to the threads topic and answer the question. If there is a place to check that Eibach supports cats then show it or say where it can be found.
My own finding points in the direction that Eibach don’t support cats but everybody think they do. So let's try to find some evidence.
Last time I looked, Bilsteins were the only aftermarket CATS shocks available, and only in "comfort" (not "sport" for XJR). They were ~ $3,200 the set
Please stick to the threads topic and answer the question. If there is a place to check that Eibach supports cats then show it or say where it can be found.
My own finding points in the direction that Eibach don’t support cats but everybody think they do. So let's try to find some evidence.
Last edited by spalmgre; 05-25-2022 at 11:40 AM.
#10
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I purchased them online somewhere and can not recall the vendor without looking back in my purchase history. They were about $2500 for the front if I recall correctly . I installed a new OEM compressor at the same time and have not had a fault since . The packaging was all legit and they were perfect looking . But the "install by" date code sticker was expired and there seemed to be an older date sticker below that one. I think they sat on a shelf for years unfortunately. But I needed to proceed and I installed them.
My old front air springs were from an aftermarket co starting with an A. One of them was loose inside and clunking/knocking . Plus they had different dampening properties and the front was wobbling badly over heavy dips in the road.
#11
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I wish there were more options.
It appears the Bilstein have disappeared, at least in US. Only replacement shock with CATS is a rebuild. Not good.
The expiration date on the Bilstein was a huge concern. If the shelf live is a couple years what was the road life?
We may end up with coil overs.
Several other manufacturers of struts dance around CAT system. But none so far seem to actually have a working variable dampening system.
I was excited about the MaxSpeedingRods struts. Cheap and good reviews. But seems real feedback is not as glowing as website reviews. Hope this is wrong.
It appears the Bilstein have disappeared, at least in US. Only replacement shock with CATS is a rebuild. Not good.
The expiration date on the Bilstein was a huge concern. If the shelf live is a couple years what was the road life?
We may end up with coil overs.
Several other manufacturers of struts dance around CAT system. But none so far seem to actually have a working variable dampening system.
I was excited about the MaxSpeedingRods struts. Cheap and good reviews. But seems real feedback is not as glowing as website reviews. Hope this is wrong.
#12
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I replaced my air shocks with BC racing shocks with the Swift spring option. I like the way the XJR rides now but don't have a good comparison with OEM air shocks. Shortly after buying my 04 XJR I developed an air leak in one of the front shocks. I decided to switch over to springs before spending any money on the air system. The leaking shock was a rebuilt one and also a comfort shock for non-supercharged AJ's.
#13
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
https://www.autohausaz.com/pn/17920_...BoCj7AQAvD_BwE
I haven't tried to see if they are in stock, but this place might have some .
I haven't tried to see if they are in stock, but this place might have some .
#14
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
[QUOTE=spalmgre;2528753]
- EIBACH produces only coil spring suspension without CATS adaption and no air suspension. I don't know who all thinks Eibach supports CATS (with coil springs) and there will be no proof of that.
- BILSTEIN produces Air spring struts type B4, which according to the catalog is a replacement for both comfort and sport suspensions.
If replacement for the expensive Bilstein OEM is sought probably only one of the two Arnott variants makes sense.
Fritz
OEM is Bilstein
Last time I looked, Bilsteins were the only aftermarket CATS shocks available, and only in "comfort" (not "sport" for XJR). They were ~ $3,200 the set
Please stick to the threads topic and answer the question. If there is a place to check that Eibach supports cats then show it or say where it can be found.
My own finding points in the direction that Eibach don’t support cats but everybody think they do. So let's try to find some evidence.
Last time I looked, Bilsteins were the only aftermarket CATS shocks available, and only in "comfort" (not "sport" for XJR). They were ~ $3,200 the set
Please stick to the threads topic and answer the question. If there is a place to check that Eibach supports cats then show it or say where it can be found.
My own finding points in the direction that Eibach don’t support cats but everybody think they do. So let's try to find some evidence.
- BILSTEIN produces Air spring struts type B4, which according to the catalog is a replacement for both comfort and sport suspensions.
If replacement for the expensive Bilstein OEM is sought probably only one of the two Arnott variants makes sense.
Fritz
Last edited by flatsix; 05-25-2022 at 05:19 PM.
#15
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
#18
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
It is reported the Misseler or whatever air struts have variable dampening. I read the company provided specs and it was not clear.
Several companies have kind of danced around this with vague statements. But none I know of have even the rudimentary system Jaguar had installed in the x350 series. But knowing a little more about it, this explains how flat my XJR corners. I can see the value since there are no anti roll bar upgrades.
Several companies have kind of danced around this with vague statements. But none I know of have even the rudimentary system Jaguar had installed in the x350 series. But knowing a little more about it, this explains how flat my XJR corners. I can see the value since there are no anti roll bar upgrades.
#20
![Default](/forum/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I replaced all 4 corners of my '04 XJR with Arnott. It's been said something is different, but I haven't noticed anything different from the Original struts that were replaced. Except the Arnotts hold air...lol. I still here the air exchange upon braking and the car adjusts ride height from standing/parked to driving ride height.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)