How good is your heater??
#1
How good is your heater??
I'm aware of the issues with heater pumps, but understand them to usually manifest as a heater that suddenly doesn't produce hot air. My heater gets warm, but not really as hot as I'd expect - is this 'normal', or is there something I can do about it?!
Ta for any input Fingers crossed, I'll be able to spend a bit of time on the car at the weekend - I've got plenty lined up to do!
Ta for any input Fingers crossed, I'll be able to spend a bit of time on the car at the weekend - I've got plenty lined up to do!
#2
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,894
Received 10,952 Likes
on
7,196 Posts
Many complaints over the years regarding weak-ish X300 heaters, including from me. Poor design? or a fault shared by many cars? I dunno.
In full Auto mode the system wants to warm us very gently, it seems. When I want a real blast of heat I manually adjust the settings....sorta "browbeat" the system to give me toasty air.
Let's hear what othes have to say
Cheers
DD
In full Auto mode the system wants to warm us very gently, it seems. When I want a real blast of heat I manually adjust the settings....sorta "browbeat" the system to give me toasty air.
Let's hear what othes have to say
Cheers
DD
#3
Interesting - that's about the same as mine Doug, I've not tried very hard to see how hot it can get though, as it's not got that cold here yet!
My previous daily-driver had a dealer-fit aircon system, which made for vague air conditioning and a far-poorer-than-standard heater. I'd like to get back to being warm in the winter if that's not too much to ask!
My previous daily-driver had a dealer-fit aircon system, which made for vague air conditioning and a far-poorer-than-standard heater. I'd like to get back to being warm in the winter if that's not too much to ask!
#4
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,894
Received 10,952 Likes
on
7,196 Posts
I crank the temp to max heat and manually go to a higher fan speed to get my toes warm....then *gradually* reduce the temp setting. Once the chill is gone I revert to "auto" setting and all's well after that.
I've had many cars with auto climate control. To be honest only one (Ser III XJ6) behaved as I would prefer/expect. In all other cases I've found the systems to be less responsive than I'd like when heat is called for. The X300s are just particularly lazy, IMHO.
Cheers
DD
#5
You're probably right - as long as I can get a decent amount of heat out of it somehow, that'll do! To be honest, I never had a problem with manual controls, but 'progress' is inevitable...
While we're on the subject, whenever the HVAC is turned on it produces a buzzing noise, seemingly from the area of the far right air vent. Anything you've seen before?
While we're on the subject, whenever the HVAC is turned on it produces a buzzing noise, seemingly from the area of the far right air vent. Anything you've seen before?
#6
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,894
Received 10,952 Likes
on
7,196 Posts
You're probably right - as long as I can get a decent amount of heat out of it somehow, that'll do! To be honest, I never had a problem with manual controls, but 'progress' is inevitable...
While we're on the subject, whenever the HVAC is turned on it produces a buzzing noise, seemingly from the area of the far right air vent. Anything you've seen before?
While we're on the subject, whenever the HVAC is turned on it produces a buzzing noise, seemingly from the area of the far right air vent. Anything you've seen before?
Aspirator fan, perhaps? On LHD drive cars it's located on the left under-dash panel. I'm *assuming* the opposite on a RHD car....mounted in the right side under-dash panel.
They're known to buzz. Remove, clean, add a tiny drop of light machine oil to the shaft. Oddly, mine would buzz *only* when turning right.
Cheers
DD
#7
Trending Topics
#8
#10
Worth considering! Having had a fiddle on the way home last night, it does get hot, just not quite as hot as I'd like. The temp gauge behaves as I'd expect, but a new thermostat couldn't hurt anyway - these things don't last forever!
It seems that the dial for the temperature of the centre vents doesn't do a great deal - the air temp is as for the other vents, whatever position the dial's in. Unless that's likely to be a simple fix though, I really don't care very much!
It seems that the dial for the temperature of the centre vents doesn't do a great deal - the air temp is as for the other vents, whatever position the dial's in. Unless that's likely to be a simple fix though, I really don't care very much!
#11
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,894
Received 10,952 Likes
on
7,196 Posts
That's fine, but if the temp gauges reaches "N" that's as good as it get with respect to the heater.
The thermo stuck "open" on my car years ago....on a small road trip in the dead of winter. Talk about cold toes ! :-)
It seems that the dial for the temperature of the centre vents doesn't do a great deal - the air temp is as for the other vents, whatever position the dial's in. Unless that's likely to be a simple fix though, I really don't care very much!
That's just a "trim" adjustment. By design it's a rather subtle thing. Yours is probably OK.
Cheers
DD
#12
It sits just below N - I'd assumed that was about normal... certainly behaves as you'd expect WRT time taken to get there & not moving once it's there.
I hadn't realised that about the centre vent, obviously! I've previously had cars with a similar arrangement that allows cold air on your face & warm on your feet... Nice to know it's probably as it should be - I don't like putting up with things not being right, even if they make no difference to me.
Perhaps if I eventually get the to-do list whittled down, I'll add a retro-fit of some heated seats... Mind you, I really should get round to doing some work on my other car if I ever get the chance!
I hadn't realised that about the centre vent, obviously! I've previously had cars with a similar arrangement that allows cold air on your face & warm on your feet... Nice to know it's probably as it should be - I don't like putting up with things not being right, even if they make no difference to me.
Perhaps if I eventually get the to-do list whittled down, I'll add a retro-fit of some heated seats... Mind you, I really should get round to doing some work on my other car if I ever get the chance!
#13
#14
#15
It requires whatever was there when you pulled it apart....even so an o-ring comes in the box, not a gasket. The housing breaks very easily, btw...even though you are forewarned.....STILL breaks easily...
#16
Hmmm... despite my efforts to convince myself otherwise, it's definitely not right - I shouldn't still be chilly after a half hour drive with the heater on as hot as it goes!
I'll order a new thermostat, but I'm still suspicious that there's something not quite right about the heater pump/valve.
I'll order a new thermostat, but I'm still suspicious that there's something not quite right about the heater pump/valve.
#17
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,894
Received 10,952 Likes
on
7,196 Posts
Hmmm... despite my efforts to convince myself otherwise, it's definitely not right - I shouldn't still be chilly after a half hour drive with the heater on as hot as it goes!
I'll order a new thermostat, but I'm still suspicious that there's something not quite right about the heater pump/valve.
I'll order a new thermostat, but I'm still suspicious that there's something not quite right about the heater pump/valve.
The pumps are known to fail.
Some guys have luck with DIY brush replacement....that's always seems to be the fault, worn brushes...sourced from a hobby store
Others remove the pump and/or valve and toss it over the hedge, re-routing the hoses in a conventional manner. I can't remember the details on that, but I know it's been done.
If your temp gauge shows "N" that's as good as it gets with respect to the heater. I don't see the point of replacing the thermo.
Cheers
DD
#18
The pumps are known to fail.
Some guys have luck with DIY brush replacement....that's always seems to be the fault, worn brushes...sourced from a hobby store
Others remove the pump and/or valve and toss it over the hedge, re-routing the hoses in a conventional manner. I can't remember the details on that, but I know it's been done.
If your temp gauge shows "N" that's as good as it gets with respect to the heater. I don't see the point of replacing the thermo.
Cheers
DD
Some guys have luck with DIY brush replacement....that's always seems to be the fault, worn brushes...sourced from a hobby store
Others remove the pump and/or valve and toss it over the hedge, re-routing the hoses in a conventional manner. I can't remember the details on that, but I know it's been done.
If your temp gauge shows "N" that's as good as it gets with respect to the heater. I don't see the point of replacing the thermo.
Cheers
DD
I'm not expecting the thermostat change to fix it, but having seen the state of most other maintenance parts on the car, I'm going to change it anyway! Likewise with my temperature sender / cold start issue - the evidence suggests it won't help, but with cheap parts that are prone to failure, I'd rather do it anyway.
I'll have a look at whether the pump is running, but I'm fairly sure I'll be able to swap the brushes if that's likely to be all that's wrong with it - I've got plenty of those spare from when I used to have time for such frivolities as RC cars!
#19
So, the pump works fine (tested it off the car as well as confirming it 'buzzes' when it should) and I do get hot air - just not much of it!
Temp to Hi, AC off, auto off, vents to face. With the fan set to anything up to 4, the air is hot. Above that, it gets progressively cooler.
Heater valve doing something weird? Matrix blocked? Airlock? Thoughts on a postcard...!
Edit: I've changed the thermostat btw!
Temp to Hi, AC off, auto off, vents to face. With the fan set to anything up to 4, the air is hot. Above that, it gets progressively cooler.
Heater valve doing something weird? Matrix blocked? Airlock? Thoughts on a postcard...!
Edit: I've changed the thermostat btw!
Last edited by Ziggy; 12-06-2012 at 08:56 AM.
#20