Mystery clicking noise from near throttle body - is this normal?
#21
Well you know it does sound like a blender. What's odd to me is that it was quiet till I tightened those 2 bolts joining the throttle elbow to the supercharger.
I searched and found a lot of posts about the solid coupler and even a video that sounds just like my car. I guess it's possible that the coupler has been replaced with a solid one or that the original one has failed. Looks like if you want it quiet you need the OEM unit with the spring. Ebay only seems to have the solid ones or an oil filled "upgrade".
Is there any way to diagnose the coupler issue other than stripping it down? Anyone tried the oil filled nylon replacements?
I searched and found a lot of posts about the solid coupler and even a video that sounds just like my car. I guess it's possible that the coupler has been replaced with a solid one or that the original one has failed. Looks like if you want it quiet you need the OEM unit with the spring. Ebay only seems to have the solid ones or an oil filled "upgrade".
Is there any way to diagnose the coupler issue other than stripping it down? Anyone tried the oil filled nylon replacements?
Last edited by mike32966; 05-17-2021 at 07:27 PM.
#22
Well you know it does sound like a blender. What's odd to me is that it was quiet till I tightened those 2 bolts joining the throttle elbow to the supercharger.
I searched and found a lot of posts about the solid coupler and even a video that sounds just like my car. I guess it's possible that the coupler has been replaced with a solid one. Looks like if you want it quiet you need the OEM unit with the spring.
Is there any way to diagnose the coupler issue other than stripping it down? Anyone tried the oil filled nylon replacements?
I searched and found a lot of posts about the solid coupler and even a video that sounds just like my car. I guess it's possible that the coupler has been replaced with a solid one. Looks like if you want it quiet you need the OEM unit with the spring.
Is there any way to diagnose the coupler issue other than stripping it down? Anyone tried the oil filled nylon replacements?
#25
#27
The coupling only is also available (Range Rover Sport 4.2 Supercharger OEM Sprung Coupler Isolator 2008 2009 | eBay) but too expensive. Add $50 and get the kit. You can use the coupler and the oil and keep the other parts for any later refurbishment.
#28
Scottjh9, thanks for the offer, much appreciated. Part of me wants to jump on that offer but there's a nagging voice telling me I don't want to put in a used part and potentially have to do the job again if it fails. It seems like heat cycles are the enemy of these plastic components so new is the way to go.
I found one for about $60 + shipping https://superchargerparts.com/index....n-coupler.html or https://superchargersonline.com/prod...aded-isolator/ with higher shipping costs
-Mike
.
I found one for about $60 + shipping https://superchargerparts.com/index....n-coupler.html or https://superchargersonline.com/prod...aded-isolator/ with higher shipping costs
-Mike
.
#31
Last edited by scottjh9; 05-19-2021 at 09:14 PM.
#32
I pulled the supercharger out today. The coupler doesn't show any signs of damage but the spring could be weak.
Turning the rotors by hand creates a knock on each rotation, it's not as bad rotating the opposite direction. I've attached a recording. I'm thinking this isn't normal and it should rotate smoothly. Not sure where to go from here.
Turning the rotors by hand creates a knock on each rotation, it's not as bad rotating the opposite direction. I've attached a recording. I'm thinking this isn't normal and it should rotate smoothly. Not sure where to go from here.
#33
#34
Alternatively, you can send it to a specialist for a complete rebuild or get a good used one.
#35
Since you get knocking when turning the rotors directly (nose piece removed). the problem appears to be in the rotor bearings. As the front ones are not easily replaceable (specialist workshop job), you can try with replacing the two rear needle bearings. It would be a good practice to also replace the two nose piece bearings even though it seems that the problem is not there.
Alternatively, you can send it to a specialist for a complete rebuild or get a good used one.
Alternatively, you can send it to a specialist for a complete rebuild or get a good used one.
#36
I pulled the supercharger rotors out . The needle bearings look ok. There's no scoring on the rotor stubs that go into the bearings and both are the same size so don't appear to have worn. I could rotate the needles ok and there didn't seem to be any signs of damage. Plenty of blue grease in one, little less in the other but not dry. Not sure what else to look for.
There was a lot of carbon build up on the rotors - picture below. I cleaned them with carb cleaner, the Teflon coating had worn through in just one spot - second pic pic below - but otherwise they cleaned up pretty well. No signs of rubbing on the rotors or the casing. I put some extra lithium grease in the bearing and reinstalled and the knock seems to be gone. There's still some noise from the rotors rotating but I'm thinking that may be normal or at least ok to live with - attaching an mp3. Let me know what you think, is this the normal sound? It's more a regular mechanical noise and no knocking like in the last recording.
Option 1 - get a used unit, found one near me for about $500, May be no better that one I have.
Option 2 - reinstall this one with the new coupler, save $500 but maybe have to go in there again if it doesn't work out. It was a lot quieter until I tightened up those 2 elbow bolts and it was the knocking that concerned me.
I'm leaning towards option 2.
Anyone know if it's ok to use a regular synthetic grease in the needle bearings or is there something special about that blue grease?
Thanks for all the helpful advice, truly appreciate your input.
Mike
Before cleaning, carbon build up on rotors
After cleaning, one spot with missing teflon
There was a lot of carbon build up on the rotors - picture below. I cleaned them with carb cleaner, the Teflon coating had worn through in just one spot - second pic pic below - but otherwise they cleaned up pretty well. No signs of rubbing on the rotors or the casing. I put some extra lithium grease in the bearing and reinstalled and the knock seems to be gone. There's still some noise from the rotors rotating but I'm thinking that may be normal or at least ok to live with - attaching an mp3. Let me know what you think, is this the normal sound? It's more a regular mechanical noise and no knocking like in the last recording.
Option 1 - get a used unit, found one near me for about $500, May be no better that one I have.
Option 2 - reinstall this one with the new coupler, save $500 but maybe have to go in there again if it doesn't work out. It was a lot quieter until I tightened up those 2 elbow bolts and it was the knocking that concerned me.
I'm leaning towards option 2.
Anyone know if it's ok to use a regular synthetic grease in the needle bearings or is there something special about that blue grease?
Thanks for all the helpful advice, truly appreciate your input.
Mike
Before cleaning, carbon build up on rotors
After cleaning, one spot with missing teflon
#37
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
944xjs
XJS ( X27 )
11
04-25-2021 10:22 AM
vincent661983
XJ XJ8 / XJR ( X308 )
4
10-29-2018 07:58 PM
jaguars-type
S-Type / S type R Supercharged V8 ( X200 )
13
02-26-2010 07:18 PM
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)