replacement shocks, your opinions?
#21
#22
the shop sez my front shocks are worn out. the lower bushings do rattle. i'm curious, which are your favorite replacement shocks? i'm thinking either Bilstein or KYB, but honestly, i have no experience with air suspensions as on the X308s. i see comments about replacing with coil-overs, struts? and completely eliminating the air system. pls educate me.
i like a nice ride. firm and responsive, but am not looking to run on the track. just a classy comfortable ride with good handling.
ideas? i have great respect for the Voice(s) of Experience on this Forum.
i like a nice ride. firm and responsive, but am not looking to run on the track. just a classy comfortable ride with good handling.
ideas? i have great respect for the Voice(s) of Experience on this Forum.
#23
Thanks!!
Chris
2001 XJR
Last edited by Badbenz94; 08-12-2013 at 09:49 PM.
#24
Chris,
As near as I can tell, there are 3 types of Bilstein shocks offered for the non CATS X308:
Comfort: put in new by Jaguar
Heavy Duty (HD) What I just put in my 2001 XJR
Sport: Stiff ride/for track use
The choice is up to you depending on how you use your car. I use mine for business, and wanted a comfortable, responsive but not "floaty" ride. To that end, the HDs are perfect on the XJR in my opinion. I feel a few more bumps with the HDs, but the trade off for me is a feeling of better and more controlled ride. I don't believe Jaguar ever specified the "Sport" shocks on any of the X308 line, but certainly it is an option as a replacement.
As near as I can tell, there are 3 types of Bilstein shocks offered for the non CATS X308:
Comfort: put in new by Jaguar
Heavy Duty (HD) What I just put in my 2001 XJR
Sport: Stiff ride/for track use
The choice is up to you depending on how you use your car. I use mine for business, and wanted a comfortable, responsive but not "floaty" ride. To that end, the HDs are perfect on the XJR in my opinion. I feel a few more bumps with the HDs, but the trade off for me is a feeling of better and more controlled ride. I don't believe Jaguar ever specified the "Sport" shocks on any of the X308 line, but certainly it is an option as a replacement.
#26
Chris,
As near as I can tell, there are 3 types of Bilstein shocks offered for the non CATS X308:
Comfort: put in new by Jaguar
Heavy Duty (HD) What I just put in my 2001 XJR
Sport: Stiff ride/for track use
The choice is up to you depending on how you use your car. I use mine for business, and wanted a comfortable, responsive but not "floaty" ride. To that end, the HDs are perfect on the XJR in my opinion. I feel a few more bumps with the HDs, but the trade off for me is a feeling of better and more controlled ride. I don't believe Jaguar ever specified the "Sport" shocks on any of the X308 line, but certainly it is an option as a replacement.
As near as I can tell, there are 3 types of Bilstein shocks offered for the non CATS X308:
Comfort: put in new by Jaguar
Heavy Duty (HD) What I just put in my 2001 XJR
Sport: Stiff ride/for track use
The choice is up to you depending on how you use your car. I use mine for business, and wanted a comfortable, responsive but not "floaty" ride. To that end, the HDs are perfect on the XJR in my opinion. I feel a few more bumps with the HDs, but the trade off for me is a feeling of better and more controlled ride. I don't believe Jaguar ever specified the "Sport" shocks on any of the X308 line, but certainly it is an option as a replacement.
Thank you both for the input. Im not sure I want to go any stiffer as I live in Illinois where the roads are ok at best and not very curvy except the on/off ramps lol.
Just trying to see if its worth it to replace with new or not and which model would be a direct replacement for what is currently on the car.
#28
#29
The following users liked this post:
D. Fite (10-09-2016)
#31
Bumping this. I emailed shockwarehouse about front Bils for forum members and will report back on pricing. I bought Bil tourings for my e46 from those guys and have nothing but positive things to say so far so fingers crossed on their pricing. I dropped $1455 today and while the end is in site I'll be excited for the bleeding to subside
#33
The following 3 users liked this post by fhowell:
#35
New update of Bilstein shocks
Hello everybody'
I am in the process of replacing the front & rear shocks on our 2001 XJ8.
I finished my research on the current availability and pricing for the replacement of the comfort (or so called standard) shocks that were installed by Jaguar on our XJ8.
I made sure that I ordered the right shocks - first by using the JEPC (Jaguar Electronic Parts Catalog) to get the Jaguar part numbers.
Then I used the Bilstein website search with the Jaguar part number to get the equivalent Bilstein current and superseded part numbers.
I decided to buy the shocks from Parts Geek website based on their much lower prices than any of their competitors.
Their total delivered price for both front and rear shocks came to $$396.57
Bilstein Shock Absorber - Front
(Comfort/standard) not adaptive Jaguar part# MND2140AD
(Bilstein current part# 24-023740, superceded part#F4-BE3-2374-H0)
Parts Geek price $101.33
Advance Auto Parts price $182.66 (80% higher).
SNG Barratt USA price $215.30 (112% higher)
Bilstein Shock Absorber - Rear
(Comfort/standard) not adaptive Jaguar part# MNC3540AA
(Bilstein current part# 24-023757, superceded part# F4-BE5-2375-H0)
Parts Geek price $101.84 (Geek part# W0133-1911284)
Advance Auto Parts does not carry this part (rear shocks)
SNG Barratt USA price $215.30 (111% higher)
Advance Auto Parts does not allow use of any of their promotion codes on the Bilstein shocks.
I also compiled the same information on the Bilstein adaptive (comfort/standard and sport) and the non-adaptive Bilstein sports shocks.
Click on attachment - Microsoft Excel worksheet
2001 jaguar xj shock absorbers reference list.xls
Shocks are in transit. I will update this tread after I receive and have them installed.
I am in the process of replacing the front & rear shocks on our 2001 XJ8.
I finished my research on the current availability and pricing for the replacement of the comfort (or so called standard) shocks that were installed by Jaguar on our XJ8.
I made sure that I ordered the right shocks - first by using the JEPC (Jaguar Electronic Parts Catalog) to get the Jaguar part numbers.
Then I used the Bilstein website search with the Jaguar part number to get the equivalent Bilstein current and superseded part numbers.
I decided to buy the shocks from Parts Geek website based on their much lower prices than any of their competitors.
Their total delivered price for both front and rear shocks came to $$396.57
Bilstein Shock Absorber - Front
(Comfort/standard) not adaptive Jaguar part# MND2140AD
(Bilstein current part# 24-023740, superceded part#F4-BE3-2374-H0)
Parts Geek price $101.33
Advance Auto Parts price $182.66 (80% higher).
SNG Barratt USA price $215.30 (112% higher)
Bilstein Shock Absorber - Rear
(Comfort/standard) not adaptive Jaguar part# MNC3540AA
(Bilstein current part# 24-023757, superceded part# F4-BE5-2375-H0)
Parts Geek price $101.84 (Geek part# W0133-1911284)
Advance Auto Parts does not carry this part (rear shocks)
SNG Barratt USA price $215.30 (111% higher)
Advance Auto Parts does not allow use of any of their promotion codes on the Bilstein shocks.
I also compiled the same information on the Bilstein adaptive (comfort/standard and sport) and the non-adaptive Bilstein sports shocks.
Click on attachment - Microsoft Excel worksheet
2001 jaguar xj shock absorbers reference list.xls
Shocks are in transit. I will update this tread after I receive and have them installed.
The following 3 users liked this post by jimlombardi:
#36
#37
Pricing as of today 10-20-2023:
Parts Geek - Bilstein E4 shocks, set of four ~$573 w/shipping
Parts Geek - KYB shocks, set of four ~$383 w/shipping
Amazon - Bilstein E4 shocks, set of four ~$540 w/shipping
Amazon - KYB shocks, set of four ~$350 w/shipping
RockAuto - Bilstein E4 shocks, set of four ~$440 + $33 shipping = $473
Parts Geek - Bilstein E4 shocks, set of four ~$573 w/shipping
Parts Geek - KYB shocks, set of four ~$383 w/shipping
Amazon - Bilstein E4 shocks, set of four ~$540 w/shipping
Amazon - KYB shocks, set of four ~$350 w/shipping
RockAuto - Bilstein E4 shocks, set of four ~$440 + $33 shipping = $473
#38
#39
It depends what you're used to, my Italian friend says the XJR is 'soft' - it has supersport suspension. The chassis is very sensitive to tire pressures the bigger the wheel size and smaller the depth, It's also hard setting default if there is an issue in the CATS system. C code scan to confirm.
Last edited by Sean B; 10-21-2023 at 03:56 PM.
#40
Yep it is a matter of taste. My old daily driver car was nineties Volvo luxury one that has soft suspension. I'm quessing it is softer than what x308 has with comfort suspension. Current daily driver is s80 Volvo with std suspension. That is as stiff as xjr with sport suspension at soft state.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
FastKat
XJ6 & XJ12 Series I, II & III
2
06-19-2012 02:04 PM
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)