XJ6/12 as family car
#21
Join Date: Mar 2014
Location: Tehama County, California, USA
Posts: 25,581
Received 9,384 Likes
on
5,442 Posts
The following users liked this post:
Grant Francis (05-10-2021)
#22
The following 2 users liked this post by Frank M:
Grant Francis (05-14-2021),
Junkyardjohn (05-14-2021)
#23
I've got two S3's and as mentioned, they're mostly very reliable, easy to work on (get the company workshop manual), and because so many were produced, both used and new parts are usually easily found. I prefer the later S3's (1983+) because of lower mileage and some occasional build issues during the earlier period. Most common (& easiest) repair: window switches & bulbs. As mentioned, the a/c can be a problem - if needing repair, you'll probably have to have the whole system converted to R134 unless already done. If you do, get good quality parts and a warranted repair - I had to have mine done 3 times in a year! In the US, look for a Western car if possible - less likelihood of major rust.
Good luck - these are beautiful cars.
Good luck - these are beautiful cars.
The following users liked this post:
Junkyardjohn (05-14-2021)
#24
The following 2 users liked this post by Jose:
Junkyardjohn (05-14-2021),
Mkii250 (05-14-2021)
#25
Having an older car as a daily family car is possible, especially if it is not an only car. Issues will pop up that need to be attended to, and with a family you'll need a reliable late model available. Be sure that the suspension is in perfect shape before you b uy. I find that I dislike suspension work the most, since you've got to get down to it's level. Good luck, let us know what you end up with. Oh, I'll throw my two cents in, an X300 is almost as beautiful as a Series Three and is much more modern.
The following 2 users liked this post by Rivguy:
Grant Francis (05-14-2021),
Junkyardjohn (05-14-2021)
#26
Hi,
I’m contemplating an XJ as car to use a few times a week, not a daily. I’ve got a baby and a toddler. My father used to own a series 1 that I learned to drive in, hence the reason for wanting one now. So my question is, what is the best series/model to get?
I’ve found series 1 to be to expensive. Considering these cars are getting old the mileage is high. What kms are considered too high for a v12 or 6? I’m experienced working on old cars, efi scares me more than carbs. Any recommendations?
I’m contemplating an XJ as car to use a few times a week, not a daily. I’ve got a baby and a toddler. My father used to own a series 1 that I learned to drive in, hence the reason for wanting one now. So my question is, what is the best series/model to get?
I’ve found series 1 to be to expensive. Considering these cars are getting old the mileage is high. What kms are considered too high for a v12 or 6? I’m experienced working on old cars, efi scares me more than carbs. Any recommendations?
Last edited by back in the seat; 05-13-2021 at 05:37 PM.
The following 2 users liked this post by back in the seat:
Junkyardjohn (05-14-2021),
Mkii250 (05-14-2021)
#27
more opinionated opinions:
I would not judge a Series 3 by its mileage. The speedometer can be replaced in under 5 minutes with one that has less mileage.
the later cars after the Series 3 ( XJ-40 onwards), depend on many digital circuit boards that burn out, are expensive to replace and difficult to diagnose.
If you want to confirm that opinion, go to the XJ-40, X300, X350 forums and read what owners report about those cars.
I prefer the analog Jaguar, where little if any digital components were used. The most modern of those is the Series 3 XJ. After that, all hell broke lose and Jags started to look like glorified Fords or Toyotas.
I would not judge a Series 3 by its mileage. The speedometer can be replaced in under 5 minutes with one that has less mileage.
the later cars after the Series 3 ( XJ-40 onwards), depend on many digital circuit boards that burn out, are expensive to replace and difficult to diagnose.
If you want to confirm that opinion, go to the XJ-40, X300, X350 forums and read what owners report about those cars.
I prefer the analog Jaguar, where little if any digital components were used. The most modern of those is the Series 3 XJ. After that, all hell broke lose and Jags started to look like glorified Fords or Toyotas.
The following 4 users liked this post by Jose:
#28
The following users liked this post:
Junkyardjohn (05-14-2021)
#29
more opinionated opinions:
I would not judge a Series 3 by its mileage. The speedometer can be replaced in under 5 minutes with one that has less mileage.
the later cars after the Series 3 ( XJ-40 onwards), depend on many digital circuit boards that burn out, are expensive to replace and difficult to diagnose.
If you want to confirm that opinion, go to the XJ-40, X300, X350 forums and read what owners report about those cars.
I prefer the analog Jaguar, where little if any digital components were used. The most modern of those is the Series 3 XJ. After that, all hell broke lose and Jags started to look like glorified Fords or Toyotas.
I would not judge a Series 3 by its mileage. The speedometer can be replaced in under 5 minutes with one that has less mileage.
the later cars after the Series 3 ( XJ-40 onwards), depend on many digital circuit boards that burn out, are expensive to replace and difficult to diagnose.
If you want to confirm that opinion, go to the XJ-40, X300, X350 forums and read what owners report about those cars.
I prefer the analog Jaguar, where little if any digital components were used. The most modern of those is the Series 3 XJ. After that, all hell broke lose and Jags started to look like glorified Fords or Toyotas.
The following 3 users liked this post by back in the seat:
#30
back in the seat,
yes, the driver's seat is a good witness to the condition of the car. The flattened seat foam in particular.
and not many owners keep a maintenance log. The mileage cannot be used. Not saying that car sellers do it on purpose to misrepresent the mileage, but the speedos and tachs fail and need to be replaced.
Even the Service Manual shows how to test for a not working speedo. The factory knew they fail.
yes, the driver's seat is a good witness to the condition of the car. The flattened seat foam in particular.
and not many owners keep a maintenance log. The mileage cannot be used. Not saying that car sellers do it on purpose to misrepresent the mileage, but the speedos and tachs fail and need to be replaced.
Even the Service Manual shows how to test for a not working speedo. The factory knew they fail.
#31
Compared to the later cars the SIII is the easiest to live with if you plan on keeping it a long time (some of this pertains to the SIIs as well) - most of the electrical bits including switches can be taken apart and cleaned to restore to working order. The mechanical bits can be repaired with ordinary hand tools and parts aren't too dear.
I lived with a 2002 VDP for a decade. The V8 is nice and powerful and X308s resemble the older cars somewhat. Unfortunately craptastic plastic parts dominate the car under the hood and these will break, causing air intake and coolant leaks, or worse (prior to mid 2001 the secondary timing chain tensioners were plastic - my car missed the change over by a month). The ABS and security modules are prone to failure and the ZF gearbox can exhibit a sticking pressure regulator valve which will destroy the A-drum in the gearbox. I personally dealt with all of these issues; the gearbox fault was the last straw so I traded it off - and I generally don't trade cars.
Can't personally vouch for the XJ40/X300 but the drive trains have a reputation for being bulletproof.
I lived with a 2002 VDP for a decade. The V8 is nice and powerful and X308s resemble the older cars somewhat. Unfortunately craptastic plastic parts dominate the car under the hood and these will break, causing air intake and coolant leaks, or worse (prior to mid 2001 the secondary timing chain tensioners were plastic - my car missed the change over by a month). The ABS and security modules are prone to failure and the ZF gearbox can exhibit a sticking pressure regulator valve which will destroy the A-drum in the gearbox. I personally dealt with all of these issues; the gearbox fault was the last straw so I traded it off - and I generally don't trade cars.
Can't personally vouch for the XJ40/X300 but the drive trains have a reputation for being bulletproof.
The following users liked this post:
Mkii250 (05-14-2021)
#32
#33
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,888
Received 10,944 Likes
on
7,190 Posts
But a durable drivetrain isn't quite the same thing a a reliable car. And reliable isn't the same as trouble-free.
Though I sold it 6-7 years ago I had an X300 has a daily driver for several years. Towards the end I was adding 15-20k miles/year. I agree it was a great car. It was very durable (sold it at 171k miles and, overall, it was holding up very well) and it was very reliable (never once refused to start, never left me stranded). But it was by no means trouble-free. I had to do a LOT of repairs during my ownership.
As good as they are the X300s are getting old and accumulating miles. This eventually takes a toll on any car.
Cheers
DD
The following users liked this post:
yachtmanbuttson (05-14-2021)
#34
back in the seat,
yes, the driver's seat is a good witness to the condition of the car. The flattened seat foam in particular.
and not many owners keep a maintenance log. The mileage cannot be used. Not saying that car sellers do it on purpose to misrepresent the mileage, but the speedos and tachs fail and need to be replaced.
Even the Service Manual shows how to test for a not working speedo. The factory knew they fail.
yes, the driver's seat is a good witness to the condition of the car. The flattened seat foam in particular.
and not many owners keep a maintenance log. The mileage cannot be used. Not saying that car sellers do it on purpose to misrepresent the mileage, but the speedos and tachs fail and need to be replaced.
Even the Service Manual shows how to test for a not working speedo. The factory knew they fail.
1996 Jaguar X300 LWB 4ltr (My Private Limo)
2001 Jaguar X Type. (Our regular run around)
#35
Compared to the later cars the SIII is the easiest to live with if you plan on keeping it a long time (some of this pertains to the SIIs as well) - most of the electrical bits including switches can be taken apart and cleaned to restore to working order. The mechanical bits can be repaired with ordinary hand tools and parts aren't too dear.
I lived with a 2002 VDP for a decade. The V8 is nice and powerful and X308s resemble the older cars somewhat. Unfortunately craptastic plastic parts dominate the car under the hood and these will break, causing air intake and coolant leaks, or worse (prior to mid 2001 the secondary timing chain tensioners were plastic - my car missed the change over by a month). The ABS and security modules are prone to failure and the ZF gearbox can exhibit a sticking pressure regulator valve which will destroy the A-drum in the gearbox. I personally dealt with all of these issues; the gearbox fault was the last straw so I traded it off - and I generally don't trade cars.
Can't personally vouch for the XJ40/X300 but the drive trains have a reputation for being bulletproof.
I lived with a 2002 VDP for a decade. The V8 is nice and powerful and X308s resemble the older cars somewhat. Unfortunately craptastic plastic parts dominate the car under the hood and these will break, causing air intake and coolant leaks, or worse (prior to mid 2001 the secondary timing chain tensioners were plastic - my car missed the change over by a month). The ABS and security modules are prone to failure and the ZF gearbox can exhibit a sticking pressure regulator valve which will destroy the A-drum in the gearbox. I personally dealt with all of these issues; the gearbox fault was the last straw so I traded it off - and I generally don't trade cars.
Can't personally vouch for the XJ40/X300 but the drive trains have a reputation for being bulletproof.
The following users liked this post:
Mkii250 (05-14-2021)
#36
Right. Durable drivetrains.
But a durable drivetrain isn't quite the same thing a a reliable car. And reliable isn't the same as trouble-free.
Though I sold it 6-7 years ago I had an X300 has a daily driver for several years. Towards the end I was adding 15-20k miles/year. I agree it was a great car. It was very durable (sold it at 171k miles and, overall, it was holding up very well) and it was very reliable (never once refused to start, never left me stranded). But it was by no means trouble-free. I had to do a LOT of repairs during my ownership.
As good as they are the X300s are getting old and accumulating miles. This eventually takes a toll on any car.
Cheers
DD
But a durable drivetrain isn't quite the same thing a a reliable car. And reliable isn't the same as trouble-free.
Though I sold it 6-7 years ago I had an X300 has a daily driver for several years. Towards the end I was adding 15-20k miles/year. I agree it was a great car. It was very durable (sold it at 171k miles and, overall, it was holding up very well) and it was very reliable (never once refused to start, never left me stranded). But it was by no means trouble-free. I had to do a LOT of repairs during my ownership.
As good as they are the X300s are getting old and accumulating miles. This eventually takes a toll on any car.
Cheers
DD
#37
Most of my problems with Jaguars have been caused by poor maintenance by previous owners. This is especially true of my Daimler Double Six. What I can't blame on POs have been the radiator blocking with sediment and rust particles in the fuel system from corrosion inside the fuel tanks. There's also been a blown transistor in the air con. The driver's seat went a bit flat and developed a crack, both of which I fixed. Most likely an X300 or X308 would have done better. And they have fewer rattles.
My Mk2 only ever stopped due to a very slight leak from the top hose dripping coolant on the distributor and for that I'll blame the PO. It's had things fail and break, but it's never stopped.
My more modern Jaguars have not lived up (or down) to the popular reputation on reliability.
Non-Jaguars that I've owned, rented or travelled in: the engine of a Chevy ambulance called to take my wife to hospital failed outside our house; Minis had water pump failures; Toyota overheated severely; Renault, the same; Mercedes didn't stop, but the stench of gear oil suggested it would soon; Alfa engine that from time to time refused to run below 3000 rpm ... .
In summary, so long as they are properly maintained, Jaguars, including series XJs, are as good as any other make. And, as I've said may times, there's something very special about a series XJ. In its day, it was the best car in the world and in many ways it still is.
My Mk2 only ever stopped due to a very slight leak from the top hose dripping coolant on the distributor and for that I'll blame the PO. It's had things fail and break, but it's never stopped.
My more modern Jaguars have not lived up (or down) to the popular reputation on reliability.
Non-Jaguars that I've owned, rented or travelled in: the engine of a Chevy ambulance called to take my wife to hospital failed outside our house; Minis had water pump failures; Toyota overheated severely; Renault, the same; Mercedes didn't stop, but the stench of gear oil suggested it would soon; Alfa engine that from time to time refused to run below 3000 rpm ... .
In summary, so long as they are properly maintained, Jaguars, including series XJs, are as good as any other make. And, as I've said may times, there's something very special about a series XJ. In its day, it was the best car in the world and in many ways it still is.
The following users liked this post:
LnrB (05-14-2021)
#38
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,888
Received 10,944 Likes
on
7,190 Posts
Yup.
With an X300 you get a lotta car for the money. They're a bargain!
Cheers
DD
#39
Most of my problems with Jaguars have been caused by poor maintenance by previous owners. This is especially true of my Daimler Double Six. What I can't blame on POs have been the radiator blocking with sediment and rust particles in the fuel system from corrosion inside the fuel tanks. There's also been a blown transistor in the air con. The driver's seat went a bit flat and developed a crack, both of which I fixed. Most likely an X300 or X308 would have done better. And they have fewer rattles.
My Mk2 only ever stopped due to a very slight leak from the top hose dripping coolant on the distributor and for that I'll blame the PO. It's had things fail and break, but it's never stopped.
My more modern Jaguars have not lived up (or down) to the popular reputation on reliability.
Non-Jaguars that I've owned, rented or travelled in: the engine of a Chevy ambulance called to take my wife to hospital failed outside our house; Minis had water pump failures; Toyota overheated severely; Renault, the same; Mercedes didn't stop, but the stench of gear oil suggested it would soon; Alfa engine that from time to time refused to run below 3000 rpm ... .
In summary, so long as they are properly maintained, Jaguars, including series XJs, are as good as any other make. And, as I've said may times, there's something very special about a series XJ. In its day, it was the best car in the world and in many ways it still is.
My Mk2 only ever stopped due to a very slight leak from the top hose dripping coolant on the distributor and for that I'll blame the PO. It's had things fail and break, but it's never stopped.
My more modern Jaguars have not lived up (or down) to the popular reputation on reliability.
Non-Jaguars that I've owned, rented or travelled in: the engine of a Chevy ambulance called to take my wife to hospital failed outside our house; Minis had water pump failures; Toyota overheated severely; Renault, the same; Mercedes didn't stop, but the stench of gear oil suggested it would soon; Alfa engine that from time to time refused to run below 3000 rpm ... .
In summary, so long as they are properly maintained, Jaguars, including series XJs, are as good as any other make. And, as I've said may times, there's something very special about a series XJ. In its day, it was the best car in the world and in many ways it still is.
Last edited by back in the seat; 05-14-2021 at 05:48 PM.
#40
[/QUOTE] Perhaps it might have been a more dependable car if they had just stuck with the original X300 4ltr straight 6. Your 1973 XJ6 is most likely a series 2 and that XJ6 shape was as good as they got it for the XJ6 design..[/QUOTE]
I wondered that since I prefer the inline sixes. Maybe they had reached the design limit on reliable power but I've seen a stock XK take a diesel turbo and 15 lb of boost and take it.
It's funny you consider my '73 a SII car. As I've been going through it I've found a mix of SI and SII components. The grille is definitely SI but the engine wiring harness is SII - it stumped me for a bit until I realized what they did.
The SIII is my favorite but I like them all and there is no reason why any of them can't be used as an everyday driver.
I wondered that since I prefer the inline sixes. Maybe they had reached the design limit on reliable power but I've seen a stock XK take a diesel turbo and 15 lb of boost and take it.
It's funny you consider my '73 a SII car. As I've been going through it I've found a mix of SI and SII components. The grille is definitely SI but the engine wiring harness is SII - it stumped me for a bit until I realized what they did.
The SIII is my favorite but I like them all and there is no reason why any of them can't be used as an everyday driver.
The following users liked this post:
back in the seat (05-16-2021)