Can I install (mechanical) fan without a shroud?
#1
Can I install (mechanical) fan without a shroud?
I am preparing to put the radiator back in today and reconnect everything.
I don't really like that clunky shroud around the big (mechanical) fan. What if I install the fan without the shroud?
Did anybody do this and running their cars without the shroud?
I assume if one tightens the fan properly, the chance are very slim that it can become unglued. Also, one can also conduct periodic checking to make sure everything is tightened properly.
Or is it a bad idea?
I don't really like that clunky shroud around the big (mechanical) fan. What if I install the fan without the shroud?
Did anybody do this and running their cars without the shroud?
I assume if one tightens the fan properly, the chance are very slim that it can become unglued. Also, one can also conduct periodic checking to make sure everything is tightened properly.
Or is it a bad idea?
#2
Join Date: Jul 2012
Location: Walnut Creek, California
Posts: 6,796
Received 2,399 Likes
on
1,880 Posts
Of course you can! Is it a good idea? Not in my view!!
The shroud's function is to allow the mechanical fan to pull air through all of the core, not just the middle.
An unshrouded fan, either electric or mechanical is cools the core less than a shrouded one.
The factory engineers are not dumb. We DIYers learned that decades ago.
Caveat. Don't risk an engine failure. Do I have real life experience there, no need to ask, it is clear....
Carl
The shroud's function is to allow the mechanical fan to pull air through all of the core, not just the middle.
An unshrouded fan, either electric or mechanical is cools the core less than a shrouded one.
The factory engineers are not dumb. We DIYers learned that decades ago.
Caveat. Don't risk an engine failure. Do I have real life experience there, no need to ask, it is clear....
Carl
The following users liked this post:
ronbros (01-04-2017)
#3
#4
In the case of the mechanical fan the shroud is important, as the fan blades are quite a distance from the rad core and without the shroud it would not suck through the core effectively. Apparently (I have been told by someone who understands the dynamics of fanned flows) an unshrouded blade does not need a shroud if it can be mounted right against the core, but the XJS mechanical fan cannot be, as the engine moves independently of the rad. Most if not all electrical fans have a guard ring round the blades that is also used to fix the fan in place. Therefore providing the electric fan is mounted close to the rad (as in 1/2 an inch away max) a shroud is not needed as the guard ring is an effective preventer of airfllow being short circuited instead if being sucked through the core. I mount mine 1/4 inch from the core. If you are worried about chafing, a foam pad between the guard ring and the rad core is a good plan too.
Greg
Greg
Last edited by Greg in France; 01-04-2017 at 12:10 PM.
The following users liked this post:
orangeblossom (01-04-2017)
#5
In the case of the mechanical fan the shroud is important, as the fan blades are quite a distance from the rad core and without the shroud it would not suck through the core effectively. Apparently (I have been told by someone who understands the dynamics of fanned flows) an unshrouded blade does not need a shroud if it can be mounted right against the core, but the XJS mechanical fan cannot be, as the engine moves independently of the rad. Most if not all electrical fans have a guard ring round the blades that is also used to fix the fan in place. Therefore providing the electric fan is mounted close to the rad (as in 1/2 an inch away max) a shroud is not needed as the guard ring is an effective preventer of airfllow being short circuited instead if being sucked through the core. I mount mine 1/4 inch from the core. If you are worried about chafing, a foam pad between the guard ring and the rad core is a good plan too.
Greg
Greg
#6
I saw a technical paper years ago from the SPE ( Society of Petroleum Engineers) about cooler performance in gas processing plants and it was looking at the shroud-fan interface. These coolers use large (up to about 15 foot diameter) fans to cool gas after it has been compressed.
The conclusion was that shroud is critical, as is the gap between the shroud and the blades. If the shroud isn't there, the air spills out the ends of the blades, and doesn't create any draw, so it can't pull any air through the radiator. In the testing, the paper said that the gap needs to be as small as possible for efficiency, and with a gap of 3/4" (on a 15 foot fan) the amount of air it could pull across the cooler core was reduced by 70%.
That's why on some electric fans you'll see the blades and shroud moulded together, so the "shroud" moves with the blades to make the blade tip gap zero, and makes the fan as efficient as possible.
So the answer is fit the shroud, and make sure the blades are actually covered by the shroud.
The conclusion was that shroud is critical, as is the gap between the shroud and the blades. If the shroud isn't there, the air spills out the ends of the blades, and doesn't create any draw, so it can't pull any air through the radiator. In the testing, the paper said that the gap needs to be as small as possible for efficiency, and with a gap of 3/4" (on a 15 foot fan) the amount of air it could pull across the cooler core was reduced by 70%.
That's why on some electric fans you'll see the blades and shroud moulded together, so the "shroud" moves with the blades to make the blade tip gap zero, and makes the fan as efficient as possible.
So the answer is fit the shroud, and make sure the blades are actually covered by the shroud.
The following 3 users liked this post by Jagboi64:
#7
The centrifugal force of the blade rotating causes a lot of turbulent air on the blade tip this reduces efficiency and causes noise. So a blade ring will improve air flow and reduce noise.
If you look at the new aircraft with the winglets these do the same thing as the shroud around the blades.
You do not need the whole radiator shrouded only a ring around the blade tips.
If you look at the new aircraft with the winglets these do the same thing as the shroud around the blades.
You do not need the whole radiator shrouded only a ring around the blade tips.
The following 3 users liked this post by warrjon: