Cherry Blossom - Restoration 1990 XJS V12
#1161
The following users liked this post:
orangeblossom (06-16-2017)
#1162
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,919
Received 10,978 Likes
on
7,211 Posts
Brilliant.
There's nothin' better than scaring off (or otherwise discouraging) customers before they've even brought the car in, eh?
Cheers
DD
The following 2 users liked this post by Doug:
orangeblossom (06-16-2017),
paulyling (06-17-2017)
#1164
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,919
Received 10,978 Likes
on
7,211 Posts
The following 2 users liked this post by Doug:
orangeblossom (06-16-2017),
paulyling (06-17-2017)
#1166
The following users liked this post:
orangeblossom (06-17-2017)
#1167
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,919
Received 10,978 Likes
on
7,211 Posts
Hi Doug
You would be surprised (or maybe you wouldn't) how many people fall for that kind of stuff and all but hand them a 'blank cheque' to fix whatever is wrong.
Where being Billed on an hourly rate, it could easily end up costing you more than you paid for the Car.
You would be surprised (or maybe you wouldn't) how many people fall for that kind of stuff and all but hand them a 'blank cheque' to fix whatever is wrong.
Where being Billed on an hourly rate, it could easily end up costing you more than you paid for the Car.
I spent 30 years in the auto repair industry. There isn't much that could surprise me .
I'm not 100% convinced that the shop who mentioned the welding was intending to be dishonest if/when you brought the car to them. Maybe, maybe not. It just struck me as a very poor way, from a business standpoint, to start off a relationship.
First, and obviously, it can be perceived as a set-up to a rip-off. And maybe that's exactly what is was. We'll never know.
But, also, such off-the-cuff dire predictions, even if made with no dishonest intent, can scare away the customers. I've seen it many times. The customer calls, explains the problem, and then hears all sorts of doom and gloom. "Might need a transmission overhaul" or "Sounds like you have burnt valves" ....or "It'll probably need a lot of welding". It used to infuriate me when my guys did that. Meanwhile, the car ends up at a competitor for what was (virtually always) a far less serious repair. The competitor not only got the customer's business but, more importantly, their trust.
The guy you spoke to should've just said "Bring the old girl in and let's see what we've got. No worries!"
OTOH, laying out a scary and expensive scenario is also a favorite way of eliminating cars that the shop simply doesn't want to be bothered with. Rather than just being honest and saying that they're unwilling or incapable of (let's say) repairing the climate control on your old Jag they'll say "It'll end up costing at least two thousand dollars, probably more"....thus ensuring you'll never darken their doorway !
Cheers
DD
The following 4 users liked this post by Doug:
Greg in France (06-18-2017),
orangeblossom (06-17-2017),
paulyling (06-18-2017),
ronbros (06-18-2017)
#1168
Hi Bro
Although I've never been conned myself, I have learned lessons from the misfortunes of others, as an ex GF from way back had a Fiat 500
which failed the MOT.
Through rusty floor panels and not knowing anything about Cars or the way Shops work, when they asked her if She wanted them to fix it, She said Yes!
And the Bill was about £500 which was more than the Car was worth and unfortunately She only told me about it after the work had been done.
Or I would have advised her to Scrap it and buy a better one, before She went and gave them a blank cheque.
Although I've never been conned myself, I have learned lessons from the misfortunes of others, as an ex GF from way back had a Fiat 500
which failed the MOT.
Through rusty floor panels and not knowing anything about Cars or the way Shops work, when they asked her if She wanted them to fix it, She said Yes!
And the Bill was about £500 which was more than the Car was worth and unfortunately She only told me about it after the work had been done.
Or I would have advised her to Scrap it and buy a better one, before She went and gave them a blank cheque.
The following users liked this post:
paulyling (06-18-2017)
#1169
Hi Doug
Your suggestion would have been far better but the way the guy was talking really put me off, as he hadn't even seen the Car
and was painting a very Black Picture.
All I wanted was an MOT. Pass or Fail and nothing more than that.
If She needed fixing, I would have taken her away and done the repairs myself.
Your suggestion would have been far better but the way the guy was talking really put me off, as he hadn't even seen the Car
and was painting a very Black Picture.
All I wanted was an MOT. Pass or Fail and nothing more than that.
If She needed fixing, I would have taken her away and done the repairs myself.
The following users liked this post:
paulyling (06-18-2017)
#1170
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,919
Received 10,978 Likes
on
7,211 Posts
Through rusty floor panels and not knowing anything about Cars or the way Shops work, when they asked her if She wanted them to fix it, She said Yes!
And the Bill was about £500 which was more than the Car was worth and unfortunately She only told me about it after the work had been done.
And the Bill was about £500 which was more than the Car was worth and unfortunately She only told me about it after the work had been done.
My policy was to let people know when they were entering that territory. If they still want the repairs done, that's fine, I'd go ahead....after taking a 50% deposit. It's pretty common for people to say "yes" and then change their mind....a couple days later, after the work is done. And abandon the car. That's why I say it's bad business....for all parties.
Cheers
DD
The following 3 users liked this post by Doug:
#1171
Hi Doug
'New Shoes on a dead horse' a very apt way of putting it.
But in my own particular case, the guy was being so negative that I was getting a really bad vibe from the 'get go'
So I just had to go with my gut and find somewhere else and this time it will be a Shop that doesn't do any repairs.
'New Shoes on a dead horse' a very apt way of putting it.
But in my own particular case, the guy was being so negative that I was getting a really bad vibe from the 'get go'
So I just had to go with my gut and find somewhere else and this time it will be a Shop that doesn't do any repairs.
The following users liked this post:
paulyling (06-18-2017)
#1172
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,919
Received 10,978 Likes
on
7,211 Posts
You were right to go elsewhere.
When asked for advice on dealing with repair shops I always tell people to go with their gut. If you get a bad vibe, there's probably a good reason. And, if you find a shop that you're comfortable with, stick with it...as there's probably a good reason for that, too.
Cheers
DD
The following 3 users liked this post by Doug:
#1173
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: Austin tx and Daytona FL.
Posts: 7,362
Received 1,236 Likes
on
943 Posts
i was talking with a guy from Netherlands(he has a 1965 Mini), he said UK was the rust capital of the car world!
i kinda think he may be right, my RHD XJS came from Kent area, I spent 2 years cutting out and replacing rusted panels.
everything all the way around the body ,i'm saying everything 360* around lower part of car!
BUT today i can say its 99% RUST FREE.
i kinda think he may be right, my RHD XJS came from Kent area, I spent 2 years cutting out and replacing rusted panels.
everything all the way around the body ,i'm saying everything 360* around lower part of car!
BUT today i can say its 99% RUST FREE.
Last edited by ronbros; 06-18-2017 at 11:13 AM.
The following users liked this post:
orangeblossom (06-18-2017)
#1174
Hi Ron
My Car has sat outside for 17 years under a Car Port in all Weathers with just a Car Cover on and it is 99% rust free.
Maybe my breathable Cover from 'Car Craft' saved the day but the one thing that She does not need is Welding.
Although I'm not counting my Chickens until after the MOT.
My Car has sat outside for 17 years under a Car Port in all Weathers with just a Car Cover on and it is 99% rust free.
Maybe my breathable Cover from 'Car Craft' saved the day but the one thing that She does not need is Welding.
Although I'm not counting my Chickens until after the MOT.
The following users liked this post:
paulyling (06-18-2017)
#1175
Hi Doug
All sorts of problems finding an MOT station round my way.
One of them has a very angular incline, that could rip the exhaust off.
Another one wanted to jack the rear under the Trailing Arm Bushes.
And another one insists you stay in the reception area, while they are doing the Test (health and safety)
So those Three are crossed off the list.
All sorts of problems finding an MOT station round my way.
One of them has a very angular incline, that could rip the exhaust off.
Another one wanted to jack the rear under the Trailing Arm Bushes.
And another one insists you stay in the reception area, while they are doing the Test (health and safety)
So those Three are crossed off the list.
The following users liked this post:
paulyling (06-19-2017)
#1176
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: Austin tx and Daytona FL.
Posts: 7,362
Received 1,236 Likes
on
943 Posts
The following 2 users liked this post by ronbros:
orangeblossom (06-18-2017),
paulyling (06-19-2017)
#1177
The following 2 users liked this post by orangeblossom:
Jonathan-W (06-19-2017),
paulyling (06-19-2017)
#1178
Hi Ron
My Car has sat outside for 17 years under a Car Port in all Weathers with just a Car Cover on and it is 99% rust free.
Maybe my breathable Cover from 'Car Craft' saved the day but the one thing that She does not need is Welding.
Although I'm not counting my Chickens until after the MOT.
My Car has sat outside for 17 years under a Car Port in all Weathers with just a Car Cover on and it is 99% rust free.
Maybe my breathable Cover from 'Car Craft' saved the day but the one thing that She does not need is Welding.
Although I'm not counting my Chickens until after the MOT.
The following 3 users liked this post by alabbasi:
#1179
Hi alabbasi
No, I didn't drive her at all or even try and turn the engine over, She just sat outside in all Weathers for 17 years!
Under a Carport open on all sides with just a Car Cover over and in all that time I never looked under that Car Cover.
On paper I should now be looking at a pile of rust but in fact She looks exactly the same as the day that I covered her up and walked away.
Which is almost 'out of the box' with 24,900 Miles on the Clock.
Although Mechanically I've had my Share of (self inflicted problems) from never Starting her up and using her.
No, I didn't drive her at all or even try and turn the engine over, She just sat outside in all Weathers for 17 years!
Under a Carport open on all sides with just a Car Cover over and in all that time I never looked under that Car Cover.
On paper I should now be looking at a pile of rust but in fact She looks exactly the same as the day that I covered her up and walked away.
Which is almost 'out of the box' with 24,900 Miles on the Clock.
Although Mechanically I've had my Share of (self inflicted problems) from never Starting her up and using her.
The following users liked this post:
paulyling (06-20-2017)
#1180
Join Date: Jul 2010
Location: Austin tx and Daytona FL.
Posts: 7,362
Received 1,236 Likes
on
943 Posts
to add info!
a good car tech from England and fameiler with Jags, i asked about the rust thing!
his opinion was around 1968 and onward, Jaguar was trying to reduce weight and strenghen the body steel.
a new type of body steel was being introduced, thinner and stronger, it was a type of tempered steel hardend and heat treated!
but it took a few years before they found it also rusted easily!!
anyone know anything along that line?
a good car tech from England and fameiler with Jags, i asked about the rust thing!
his opinion was around 1968 and onward, Jaguar was trying to reduce weight and strenghen the body steel.
a new type of body steel was being introduced, thinner and stronger, it was a type of tempered steel hardend and heat treated!
but it took a few years before they found it also rusted easily!!
anyone know anything along that line?
The following users liked this post:
paulyling (06-20-2017)