Cold Engine Whine: Crank Pulley Damper Rubber Issue
#21
This is the front side of the damper. As my photo labelling skills are not as good as yours, I'll just describe it.
I put a chalk mark at the 12 o clock position on the rubber, just to highlight it's position. The inner portion that is natural steel bolts to the crank. The pulley that has 3 belts on it, will sit in this position. The 4 bolt holes that attach the pulley to the damper are clearly seen. The outer ring is painted black.
The next photo is the back (engine) side. Again, I put a white mark on the rubber at the 12 O clock position. The tapered cone with the keyway is what fits onto the nose of the crankshaft.
I think what you have marked as the inner piece is actually the shoulder portion of the outer ring.
The last photo is on my DS420 engine, but you'll get the idea. The V12 pulley is a 3 groove, instead of only a single. It will be the smaller diameter like the left most single pulley. Since that 3 groove pulley assembly bolts to the inner portion of the damper, you can mark the smaller diameter pulley and the outer portion of the damper where you indicated in your photo.
I put a chalk mark at the 12 o clock position on the rubber, just to highlight it's position. The inner portion that is natural steel bolts to the crank. The pulley that has 3 belts on it, will sit in this position. The 4 bolt holes that attach the pulley to the damper are clearly seen. The outer ring is painted black.
The next photo is the back (engine) side. Again, I put a white mark on the rubber at the 12 O clock position. The tapered cone with the keyway is what fits onto the nose of the crankshaft.
I think what you have marked as the inner piece is actually the shoulder portion of the outer ring.
The last photo is on my DS420 engine, but you'll get the idea. The V12 pulley is a 3 groove, instead of only a single. It will be the smaller diameter like the left most single pulley. Since that 3 groove pulley assembly bolts to the inner portion of the damper, you can mark the smaller diameter pulley and the outer portion of the damper where you indicated in your photo.
Last edited by Jagboi64; 03-28-2018 at 10:18 PM. Reason: clarify terms
The following users liked this post:
Some Day, Some Day (03-28-2018)
#22
Thanks very much for that. Very helpful indeed!
So when I look underneath, I'll see Part 14 and Part 19 in the diagram assembled together as one pulley assembly, but Part 19, the triple-belt part, drives three accessories directly from the crankshaft, while the grooved/ridged one that drives (the alternator, right?) is the one that harmonically damped in the bad Jaguar engineering. But because Part 14[19!] is directly bolted to the inner ring of the damper, it won't move with respect to the inner ring and so any difference between its position and the damper's outer position will be the giveaway that something is rotten in the state of Denmark, so to speak.
Yes, based on some videos and photos I've been checking, that appears to be the case. It's not a sandwich (or a hamburger), but the rings of Saturn and Cassini's Division.
Thanks again! Very informative indeed!
PS: For labelling, I just use my image viewer. I use Faststone Image Viewer as my photo viewing program on my desktop, and it's got a very useful basic editing/labelling function as well so I don't have to break out the big Photoshop guns. It can't tilt shapes, unfortunately.
So when I look underneath, I'll see Part 14 and Part 19 in the diagram assembled together as one pulley assembly, but Part 19, the triple-belt part, drives three accessories directly from the crankshaft, while the grooved/ridged one that drives (the alternator, right?) is the one that harmonically damped in the bad Jaguar engineering. But because Part 14[19!] is directly bolted to the inner ring of the damper, it won't move with respect to the inner ring and so any difference between its position and the damper's outer position will be the giveaway that something is rotten in the state of Denmark, so to speak.
I think what you have marked as the inner piece is actually the shoulder portion of the outer ring.
Thanks again! Very informative indeed!
PS: For labelling, I just use my image viewer. I use Faststone Image Viewer as my photo viewing program on my desktop, and it's got a very useful basic editing/labelling function as well so I don't have to break out the big Photoshop guns. It can't tilt shapes, unfortunately.
Last edited by Some Day, Some Day; 03-28-2018 at 11:21 PM. Reason: Screwed up part number; Jagboi put me right.
The following users liked this post:
Jagboi64 (03-28-2018)
#23
But because Part 14 is directly bolted to the inner ring of the damper, it won't move with respect to the inner ring and so any difference between its position and the damper's outer position will be the giveaway that something is rotten in the state of Denmark, so to speak.
But otherwise, yes, you have understood correctly.
I'll look into that program. I'm using Adobe's Lightroom as my primary photo editor.
#24
#25
Well, this is interesting. I took a peek under the bonnet just now to confirm exactly where the harmonic damper is, and to see how the two parts and the belts all fitted in, and lo and behold, I found that someone had already done the white marking trick:
Hmm. That's not right....
My guess is the guys at
, as the markings still look pretty white, and they are the ones who diagnosed the slipping pulley in the first place. So that looks definitive.
The only remaining question is, why the huge discrepancy in part prices? From what XKs Unlimited says, "It is also available new as a rebuilt part (JA-EAC9693/RB) and as an aftermarket part (JA-EAC9693/X)." (And their prices are: new=$850, rebuilt=$380 (+$150 refundable core charge) and aftermarket=$254). Is there any real advantage to OEM rebuilt over aftermarket?
Hmm. That's not right....
My guess is the guys at
The only remaining question is, why the huge discrepancy in part prices? From what XKs Unlimited says, "It is also available new as a rebuilt part (JA-EAC9693/RB) and as an aftermarket part (JA-EAC9693/X)." (And their prices are: new=$850, rebuilt=$380 (+$150 refundable core charge) and aftermarket=$254). Is there any real advantage to OEM rebuilt over aftermarket?
#26
Nailed it.
Pricing, no idea, and I would be careful with ElCheapo, for reasons you stated earlier.
I had mine relaminated 20 years ago, and cost me $250 Aus. The X300 3.2ltr cost $300 about 6 years ago, but he explained the X300 was simpler to do, dunno.
Mine were all V alternator drive.
Greg:
No, the earlier 5.3 has a V for alternator drive, and the Marelli is ribbed belt drive, BUT, if you want a ballsy alternator and a ribbed drive, use the Marelli damper on the Lucas car, and it all lines up.
Pricing, no idea, and I would be careful with ElCheapo, for reasons you stated earlier.
I had mine relaminated 20 years ago, and cost me $250 Aus. The X300 3.2ltr cost $300 about 6 years ago, but he explained the X300 was simpler to do, dunno.
Mine were all V alternator drive.
Greg:
No, the earlier 5.3 has a V for alternator drive, and the Marelli is ribbed belt drive, BUT, if you want a ballsy alternator and a ribbed drive, use the Marelli damper on the Lucas car, and it all lines up.
The following 2 users liked this post by Grant Francis:
Greg in France (03-29-2018),
Some Day, Some Day (03-29-2018)
#27
XKs Unlimited's remanufactured one it is, I guess. Even if sending the old part to them is a hassle.
Although XKs Unlimited would be more reputable than some eBay guy even with a 99.3% positive reputation I guess even for aftermarket, I would hope. It's a bit more expensive than eBay, so hopefully not the bottom of the barrel.
Although XKs Unlimited would be more reputable than some eBay guy even with a 99.3% positive reputation I guess even for aftermarket, I would hope. It's a bit more expensive than eBay, so hopefully not the bottom of the barrel.
The following users liked this post:
Greg in France (03-29-2018)
#28
So the crank dampers advertised have the ribbed belt drive pulley on them, then?
Greg
#29
#30
XK's don't remanufacture, they will buy it from someone else who does. I've always found them to be expensive.
I didn't see the Ebay one as being aftermarket, unless I missed it somewhere?
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/jaguar-xj...8AAOSwnDZULexm
I didn't see the Ebay one as being aftermarket, unless I missed it somewhere?
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/jaguar-xj...8AAOSwnDZULexm
Last edited by Jagboi64; 03-29-2018 at 09:51 AM.
The following users liked this post:
Some Day, Some Day (03-29-2018)
#31
The late series III V12 saloons had the ribbed belt and a Bosch alternator. 115A I think.
#32
XK's don't remanufacture, they will buy it from someone else who does. I've always found them to be expensive.
I didn't see the Ebay one as being aftermarket, unless I missed it somewhere?
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/jaguar-xj...8AAOSwnDZULexm
I didn't see the Ebay one as being aftermarket, unless I missed it somewhere?
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/jaguar-xj...8AAOSwnDZULexm
I think I will make some enquiries at XKs. Jagbits also has a reman one, for rather more money ($596 including a $100 core charge). Does the 10% discount for forum members still apply I wonder--that would be a decent amount of savings.
All in all, it's surprisingly hard to track one of these down, and they are simply NLA new.
#33
Hi Someday
These guys have got one and its about $110 inc postage
Check them out and see what you think
Jaguar Spare Parts Supplier - Jagdaim - Australia's Largest Independant
These guys have got one and its about $110 inc postage
Check them out and see what you think
Jaguar Spare Parts Supplier - Jagdaim - Australia's Largest Independant
#34
#35
Our rebuilt Harmonic Balancer is the original Jaguar part that has been rebuilt better than any new one and comes with a Lifetime warranty:
https://www.jagbits.com/product/EAC9693-REB.html
https://www.jagbits.com/product/EAC9693-REB.html
#36
#37
Dial in: Crankshaft Damper XJS on ebay.co.uk and it is about the 4th one down and listed as Jaguar Brand New Pulley C37892 from Austrailia £108.74 + £11.13 Postage
Don't know if that is the one that you are looking for but from the Pic it looks a lot like it
And the Company is called Jagdaim
I'd send you a link but the Puter keeps dropping it for some reason maybe it will be ok when it has woken up a little bit
#38
The following users liked this post:
orangeblossom (03-30-2018)
#39
Might be worth sending an inquiry to them, I've bought stuff from them before and they were good. Ditto Prestige Spares http://www.prestige-spares.com.au
Last edited by Jagboi64; 03-30-2018 at 02:44 AM.
The following 2 users liked this post by Jagboi64:
orangeblossom (03-30-2018),
Some Day, Some Day (03-30-2018)
#40
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
dww
XK8 / XKR ( X100 )
9
01-27-2014 09:30 PM
DrkNyte
S-Type / S type R Supercharged V8 ( X200 )
2
01-10-2013 10:38 PM
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)