Fan clutch diagnosis
#1
Fan clutch diagnosis
Just double check my work here. I read a few older posts to arrive here. I had to take my XJS to work today due. to a car shortage at home. It was about 90 deg F out and in stop and go traffic (mostly stop) my temperature crossed the "N" and headed just to left of "H." Once I was moving again the temps came down but never to the middle of "N" again.
A few weeks ago I was running hot and found an electrical problem with the single electrical auxiliary fan, that's been corrected and it's coming on as it should so tonight I tested the main engine fan.
I drove the car around got it up to operating temperature and brought it back to my garage. The fan has nearly ZERO resistance when I spin it when the engine is hot. It also seems to have nearly zero resistance when cold as well.
Sounds like the clutch is bad?
1994 XJS 4.0L 2+2
A few weeks ago I was running hot and found an electrical problem with the single electrical auxiliary fan, that's been corrected and it's coming on as it should so tonight I tested the main engine fan.
I drove the car around got it up to operating temperature and brought it back to my garage. The fan has nearly ZERO resistance when I spin it when the engine is hot. It also seems to have nearly zero resistance when cold as well.
Sounds like the clutch is bad?
1994 XJS 4.0L 2+2
#2
If I recall I should spin by no more then 3-4 fan blades when hot, like barely a quarter turn. When stone cold it should move more freely but then come to a stop and not fly around like a lose wheel.
I've checked my clutch while engine reads slightly above normal it barely turns when hot. There is a Hayden heavy duty clutch you can buy that fits most jags to aside from the standard type replacement you'd find at <generic parts supplier>
I've checked my clutch while engine reads slightly above normal it barely turns when hot. There is a Hayden heavy duty clutch you can buy that fits most jags to aside from the standard type replacement you'd find at <generic parts supplier>
#3
Yes, there are fan clutches available at nearly every parts supplier near me fortunately. The rest of the balance of my cooling system looks near new. I can see what looks to be a new water pump and a nice green gasket between it, very shiny part. Nice fresh green coolant and I did a hydrocarbon test and that came out fine. Hoses all look spectacular too.
#4
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,865
Received 10,920 Likes
on
7,174 Posts
Yes
Cheers
DD
#7
Get one of the cheap digital tachometers on EBay. Takes the guesswork out of diagnosis.
Then run this procedure :
http://fanclutch.com/PicsDocs/BorgWa...ives_Only).pdf
Then run this procedure :
http://fanclutch.com/PicsDocs/BorgWa...ives_Only).pdf
Trending Topics
#8
Btw Hayden 2765 fits the 5.3, but won't come up as fitting on most websites. Notice it is only one number off from the part number typically given, which I believe is 2665. This clutch can be used, at basically the same cost, as a heavy duty replacement which features more lock-up. I have not noticed any increase noise as a result.
Also, in case it isn't described well enough, the fan test refers to the fan spinning if you give it a whirl. A long time ago I didn't understand this based on the typical description, which led me to think you shouldn't be able to spin the fan around more than 3-4 revolutions by hand before it locks solid. Instead it is referring to how much resistance the fan has when given a single good push.
Also, in case it isn't described well enough, the fan test refers to the fan spinning if you give it a whirl. A long time ago I didn't understand this based on the typical description, which led me to think you shouldn't be able to spin the fan around more than 3-4 revolutions by hand before it locks solid. Instead it is referring to how much resistance the fan has when given a single good push.
#9
Btw Hayden 2765 fits the 5.3, but won't come up as fitting on most websites. Notice it is only one number off from the part number typically given, which I believe is 2665. This clutch can be used, at basically the same cost, as a heavy duty replacement which features more lock-up. I have not noticed any increase noise as a result.
Also, in case it isn't described well enough, the fan test refers to the fan spinning if you give it a whirl. A long time ago I didn't understand this based on the typical description, which led me to think you shouldn't be able to spin the fan around more than 3-4 revolutions by hand before it locks solid. Instead it is referring to how much resistance the fan has when given a single good push.
Also, in case it isn't described well enough, the fan test refers to the fan spinning if you give it a whirl. A long time ago I didn't understand this based on the typical description, which led me to think you shouldn't be able to spin the fan around more than 3-4 revolutions by hand before it locks solid. Instead it is referring to how much resistance the fan has when given a single good push.
#10
Please put some cardboard down in behind the radiator to! Not alot of space there as it is, I managed to bolt my new fan and clutch together and slide the whole assembly in without removing anything except loosening the fan shroud...I do NOT recommend it as one wrong nudge and you'll break something. Also while there its good to inspect the fan itself as they develop structural cracks and can fly apart under high rpm causing a lot of damage. A new fan is cheap to, they come in plastic or metal.
#11
Please put some cardboard down in behind the radiator to! Not alot of space there as it is, I managed to bolt my new fan and clutch together and slide the whole assembly in without removing anything except loosening the fan shroud...I do NOT recommend it as one wrong nudge and you'll break something. Also while there its good to inspect the fan itself as they develop structural cracks and can fly apart under high rpm causing a lot of damage. A new fan is cheap to, they come in plastic or metal.
Where can I get a Metal Fan, I didn't know you could buy one, would you happen to have a Part Number for a 1990 Pre-facelift V12
#13
The following users liked this post:
orangeblossom (06-23-2018)
#15
What you have just Stumbled on could be a lot Bigger than you think! as in the UK you cannot buy the Original White Plastic Fan for these Pre-Facelift Cars anymore
And although they do a black plastic Fan, I'd rather fit a Metal one if it were possible and also do away with the Fan Clutch and from that very helpful link, it certainly looks like it's possible
Last Year my Fan Clutch seized up and so the Blades were Spinning at the Same Speed as the Engine and if anything keeping the Engine a lot Cooler, where the only downside as far as I could see
Was that it was Spinning my White Plastic Fan so Fast that I was concerned that it might Break up!
Which probably couldn't happen with a Metal Fan
Since I didn't throw that Seized Fan Clutch away, then maybe I could use that instead of having an adapter made but even keeping my New Fan Clutch, I'd certainly feel a lot happier to be Spinning a Fan with Metal Blades
I'm hoping that 'Greg' might slide by on this, as he has done a lot of R&D on this sort of Stuff
Last edited by orangeblossom; 06-23-2018 at 03:27 PM.
#16
Hi Time-Pilot
From 'Stone Cold' with the Engine off, if you give one of the Fan Blades a good 'flick' with your Finger, it should Spin no more than about one revolution (two at most)
But if it Spins round like a Bicycle Wheel, then the Fan Clutch needs changing
Though assuming that it passes that Test, when the Engine is Running and the Fan Clutch starts to warm up, then the Fan should kick up a Storm of Air enough to flatten grass under the Car
After which the Speed of the Fan should modulate according to Engine Temperature and Ambient Conditions
This is not a definitive Test but more of a Rough Guide, if you think the Fan is 'playing up'
Changing the Fan and Fan Clutch is a reasonably easy job 'in the scheme of things' but is a whole lot easier if you remove the Bonnet/Hood Struts and then tie it up in an almost vertical position being VERY CAREFUL NOT to damage the Front Grill
Or you could take the Bonnet/Hood off, if you've got enough people to help you, although its almost as easy to do it with the Bonnet/Hood Still in place, if you can tie it up Safely so that it cannot fall
Also its a lot easier if you take off the Top Closing Panel but don't go losing the Copper Washers that go on the Banjo Bolt of the Pipe that runs across the Top of the Closing Panel
Whether you take that Top Closing Panel off or leave it in place is up to you but if you decide to remove it DO NOT OVER TIGHTEN it when you put it back, or you could strip the thread in the Top of the Radiator (So Be Very Careful!)
You can see how I did mine on Page: 48 of my 'Cherry Blossom' restoration thread and here is a link to that Page that also has Photos and the reason why I decided to remove my Electric efans and then go back to Mechanical
'Cherry Blossom' restoration thread page 48
From 'Stone Cold' with the Engine off, if you give one of the Fan Blades a good 'flick' with your Finger, it should Spin no more than about one revolution (two at most)
But if it Spins round like a Bicycle Wheel, then the Fan Clutch needs changing
Though assuming that it passes that Test, when the Engine is Running and the Fan Clutch starts to warm up, then the Fan should kick up a Storm of Air enough to flatten grass under the Car
After which the Speed of the Fan should modulate according to Engine Temperature and Ambient Conditions
This is not a definitive Test but more of a Rough Guide, if you think the Fan is 'playing up'
Changing the Fan and Fan Clutch is a reasonably easy job 'in the scheme of things' but is a whole lot easier if you remove the Bonnet/Hood Struts and then tie it up in an almost vertical position being VERY CAREFUL NOT to damage the Front Grill
Or you could take the Bonnet/Hood off, if you've got enough people to help you, although its almost as easy to do it with the Bonnet/Hood Still in place, if you can tie it up Safely so that it cannot fall
Also its a lot easier if you take off the Top Closing Panel but don't go losing the Copper Washers that go on the Banjo Bolt of the Pipe that runs across the Top of the Closing Panel
Whether you take that Top Closing Panel off or leave it in place is up to you but if you decide to remove it DO NOT OVER TIGHTEN it when you put it back, or you could strip the thread in the Top of the Radiator (So Be Very Careful!)
You can see how I did mine on Page: 48 of my 'Cherry Blossom' restoration thread and here is a link to that Page that also has Photos and the reason why I decided to remove my Electric efans and then go back to Mechanical
'Cherry Blossom' restoration thread page 48
Last edited by orangeblossom; 06-24-2018 at 02:02 AM.
#17
Well this was in interesting project, all told the fan took about 30 mins to remove, probably because this is the 4.0 and there is a lot of room to work. I didn't have to remove the bonnet or tilt it forward there was plenty of room to work. But I think the cause of my overheating in traffic is now confirmed as the massive amount of junk I found between the radiator and the condenser. The pictures tell all.
It must be about 1" thick. I'll need to find a way to clean it tomorrow as I do not own a pressure washer.
The rest was a normal party.
It must be about 1" thick. I'll need to find a way to clean it tomorrow as I do not own a pressure washer.
The rest was a normal party.
#18
#20
Counter intuitive as it may seem, there are situations where spinning the fan faster results in worse cooling, not better.
Last edited by Jagboi64; 06-23-2018 at 09:59 PM.
The following users liked this post:
orangeblossom (06-25-2018)