Worn Half-Shaft/UJ - or what do you think?
#1
Worn Half-Shaft/UJ - or what do you think?
I'm re-posting this comment as I need some advice - I had added it to the bottom of my previous post and as a result not many have probably noticed it.
My issue is a 'sloppiness' in the right rear and an occasional bang over bumps. The bang could be an exhaust catching the body - I know the clearances are tight in places, but I see no marks and pushing the exhausts around gives no bang... The sloppiness is the main concern as its weird, going round a right turn slowly it's like I have a flat tire! the car moves up and down slightly and I can hear almost a rubber squashing or twisting noise so I have to slow right down (the noise relates to speed and load - making me think drive shaft/UJ)), it has the movement symptoms of a UJ worn out, but like I said they are tight and solid as a rock. The rubber cage support blocks look good and don't appear separated - even when jacking up a side they don't separate, I'm wondering if I replace those before dropping the cage to see if they are the problem, what do you guys think?
All looks really solid other than surface rust, last year I replaced: the flexible brake hose, springs and shocks, rubbers in the trailing arms. I can't find nothing loose - I can feel the bolts on the top of the cage I thought maybe loose, the diff bolts are tight and more importantly I've pulled back the covers on the UJ's on the right hand half shaft - the UJ's have no play at all in them, I was expecting a worn one....
Looking at the condition of everything in the cage other than surface rust and a clean-up I don't feel the work of removing the cage is needed...other than the issue I can't track down...
My issue is a 'sloppiness' in the right rear and an occasional bang over bumps. The bang could be an exhaust catching the body - I know the clearances are tight in places, but I see no marks and pushing the exhausts around gives no bang... The sloppiness is the main concern as its weird, going round a right turn slowly it's like I have a flat tire! the car moves up and down slightly and I can hear almost a rubber squashing or twisting noise so I have to slow right down (the noise relates to speed and load - making me think drive shaft/UJ)), it has the movement symptoms of a UJ worn out, but like I said they are tight and solid as a rock. The rubber cage support blocks look good and don't appear separated - even when jacking up a side they don't separate, I'm wondering if I replace those before dropping the cage to see if they are the problem, what do you guys think?
All looks really solid other than surface rust, last year I replaced: the flexible brake hose, springs and shocks, rubbers in the trailing arms. I can't find nothing loose - I can feel the bolts on the top of the cage I thought maybe loose, the diff bolts are tight and more importantly I've pulled back the covers on the UJ's on the right hand half shaft - the UJ's have no play at all in them, I was expecting a worn one....
Looking at the condition of everything in the cage other than surface rust and a clean-up I don't feel the work of removing the cage is needed...other than the issue I can't track down...
#3
Hi Ron,
That's a good point, I don't actually know if it has an LSD but would explain to some degree some of the symptoms. I haven't checked the level as I've only just got the xjsc ladder off to start looking....still trying to decide whether to drop the cage... It has been very well maintained by a Jaguar enthusiast and has only 83K klms on it, so nothing is really worn. I've been replacing as a matter of safety all rubber components. Car runs really well other than this.
That's a good point, I don't actually know if it has an LSD but would explain to some degree some of the symptoms. I haven't checked the level as I've only just got the xjsc ladder off to start looking....still trying to decide whether to drop the cage... It has been very well maintained by a Jaguar enthusiast and has only 83K klms on it, so nothing is really worn. I've been replacing as a matter of safety all rubber components. Car runs really well other than this.
#7
Halfshaft universals ARE a wear item. To a lesser degree to others, but still need maintaining/replacing as the years mount up.
They have a grease nipple, and rarely get greased, then, as Greg in France has found, not ALL the cups get a grease supply. His thread is recent and on here, and also being a Pom, his wording is well understood.
Kms really means zero, if those stupid tin covers have not been removed, so access to the nipples is possible, as well as the visual to confirm the grease "squish" at ALL the cups. NOT an easy item to get at, but must be done annually.
They have a grease nipple, and rarely get greased, then, as Greg in France has found, not ALL the cups get a grease supply. His thread is recent and on here, and also being a Pom, his wording is well understood.
Kms really means zero, if those stupid tin covers have not been removed, so access to the nipples is possible, as well as the visual to confirm the grease "squish" at ALL the cups. NOT an easy item to get at, but must be done annually.
Last edited by Grant Francis; 12-11-2019 at 08:22 PM.
Trending Topics
#8
Hi Grant, I've been following Greg's UJ thread with keen interest, I agree those covers over them are just stupid, when I removed the ladder from my cage (XJSC) I managed to pull the covers back and check each of the four UJ cups condition, they had good signs of grease on the edge of each one and as I said earlier have no play in them I can find. When I got the car about 18 months back I did grease them up on my first maintenance routine and I recall they were pretty dry....
I'm thinking I will drop the cage after Christmas then I can do a thorough check along with all the obvious maintenance the cage drop allows.
I'm thinking I will drop the cage after Christmas then I can do a thorough check along with all the obvious maintenance the cage drop allows.
The following users liked this post:
Grant Francis (12-12-2019)
#10
Based on this experience, I am pretty convinced that changing the rear axle UJs is something that should be done after about 100,000 miles. Also convinced that they can be failing quite badly and present no obvious symptoms of failure.
The following 2 users liked this post by Greg in France:
Grant Francis (12-12-2019),
kjopen (12-12-2019)
#11
Great advice from two of the Masters
Very interesting you had no play Greg and now its much easier to turn, wonder if we all should change them considering the age of our cars now...
I've been thinking of the noise that I can hear when I get the movement on right turns, I think as whatever is tightening up (diff or UJ) as the wheel moves up and down and twists (or skips), it is probably my new trailing arm bushes that are taking the hit and that's the squishing noise.... I'd better plan on replacing those again once I've nailed the issue doing the cage drop.
Not a good idea to drop the cage this close to Christmas, the task of converting greater volumes of BEER and WINE into by product over the festive period does not make a good combination with V12 work... And I like to take my time working on my Jag, it's therapeutic and I feel I'm looking at engineering racing history albeit the XJS was not actually a race car its pedigree certainly was.
Merry Christmas Gentlemen
Very interesting you had no play Greg and now its much easier to turn, wonder if we all should change them considering the age of our cars now...
I've been thinking of the noise that I can hear when I get the movement on right turns, I think as whatever is tightening up (diff or UJ) as the wheel moves up and down and twists (or skips), it is probably my new trailing arm bushes that are taking the hit and that's the squishing noise.... I'd better plan on replacing those again once I've nailed the issue doing the cage drop.
Not a good idea to drop the cage this close to Christmas, the task of converting greater volumes of BEER and WINE into by product over the festive period does not make a good combination with V12 work... And I like to take my time working on my Jag, it's therapeutic and I feel I'm looking at engineering racing history albeit the XJS was not actually a race car its pedigree certainly was.
Merry Christmas Gentlemen
The following 2 users liked this post by kjopen:
Grant Francis (12-12-2019),
Greg in France (12-12-2019)
#12
The following 2 users liked this post by Greg in France:
Grant Francis (12-12-2019),
kjopen (12-12-2019)
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)