XJS Coolant filter question
#1
XJS Coolant filter question
I'm looking at getting coolant filtration for my XJS however I'm not impressed with the dinky inline ones various sites offer that are little more then a teabag strainer jammed in a plastic tube.
I'm wondering if anyone here has thoughts on splicing in a diesel truck spin-on coolant filter system as pictured below:
I was thinking of adding it to the return line from the heater core? I'm fairly certain the green outlined hose is the return coolant line...
I'm wondering if anyone here has thoughts on splicing in a diesel truck spin-on coolant filter system as pictured below:
I was thinking of adding it to the return line from the heater core? I'm fairly certain the green outlined hose is the return coolant line...
#2
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,911
Received 10,969 Likes
on
7,207 Posts
Where the heck would you find room to mount a big filter ?
Years and years ago many V12 owners were using Tefba filters (are those the ones you were referring to?). As I recall the consensus was that they worked great and captured lots of debris....but after all that was gone (2 or 3 filter cleanings later) there was nothing more to filter out.
It's hard to argue *against* any kind of filtration but, personally, as a purely practical matter, considering engine bay clutter, I'd consider rigging up some sort of temporary system to clean the system every few years rather than a permanently plumbed system.
That said I think the truck filter system would be fine if you can find room. You'll probably have to re-bleed the system after each filter change though.
Others will chime in.
Cheers
DD
Years and years ago many V12 owners were using Tefba filters (are those the ones you were referring to?). As I recall the consensus was that they worked great and captured lots of debris....but after all that was gone (2 or 3 filter cleanings later) there was nothing more to filter out.
It's hard to argue *against* any kind of filtration but, personally, as a purely practical matter, considering engine bay clutter, I'd consider rigging up some sort of temporary system to clean the system every few years rather than a permanently plumbed system.
That said I think the truck filter system would be fine if you can find room. You'll probably have to re-bleed the system after each filter change though.
Others will chime in.
Cheers
DD
#3
#4
Also, shoving a great big filter like that into the circuit is bound to affect coolant flow and pressure adversely, a risk I think it would be unwise to take with the engine. Believe me, the risk to your engine from a blocked filter is infinitely greater than from a bit of crud at the bottom of the rad or the block. My car has done 130,000 miles over 32 years and has never had one.
Greg
The following 2 users liked this post by Greg in France:
Daim (12-10-2016),
orangeblossom (12-10-2016)
#5
100% agree. Coolant filters are a complete waste of effort and quite unnecessary. At best they mask a system full of rubbish that needs a proper flush and service.
Also, shoving a great big filter like that into the circuit is bound to affect coolant flow and pressure adversely, a risk I think it would be unwise to take with the engine. Believe me, the risk to your engine from a blocked filter is infinitely greater than from a bit of crud at the bottom of the rad or the block. My car has done 130,000 miles over 32 years and has never had one.
Greg
Also, shoving a great big filter like that into the circuit is bound to affect coolant flow and pressure adversely, a risk I think it would be unwise to take with the engine. Believe me, the risk to your engine from a blocked filter is infinitely greater than from a bit of crud at the bottom of the rad or the block. My car has done 130,000 miles over 32 years and has never had one.
Greg
I've got some crud in my engine cooling passages. I'll flush it with clear water and done... But that'll wait until the engine is ready to run
#6
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,911
Received 10,969 Likes
on
7,207 Posts
Agreed, but so many have *not* been maintained right, as we all know!
Even after a good flushing out debris can and will continue to become dislodged *over a period of time*....and then captured by the filter if one is installed. Eventually it'll all be gone....at which point the filter becomes superfluous.
Cheers
DD
The following users liked this post:
Daim (12-10-2016)
#7
Trending Topics
#8
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: Perth Ontario Canada
Posts: 11,058
Received 2,265 Likes
on
1,845 Posts
The following users liked this post:
Daim (12-10-2016)
#9
I have a glass bowl AC Delco fuel filter slated to go into one of
the bleed lines to pickup crud. These are found in many 50's and
60's vehicles.
Betcha' Doug's seen a few of these
The glass will compensate for the small size and give a real time
view of the coolant condition. The use of the bleed line keeps the
flow restriction out of the mainstream flow circuits.
As for the need for filtration, in addition to left over crud
from neglect, casting sand bleeding out as castings erode ....
there is solids dropout and formation from the coolant itself.
Typically these are crystalised silica and silaca gel.
Both stationary and OTR diesels commonly use coolant filtration
and even have filters that introduce anti-corrosion additives back
into the coolant during use.
Factory coolant filters are also found in pleasure craft and aircraft.
the bleed lines to pickup crud. These are found in many 50's and
60's vehicles.
Betcha' Doug's seen a few of these
The glass will compensate for the small size and give a real time
view of the coolant condition. The use of the bleed line keeps the
flow restriction out of the mainstream flow circuits.
As for the need for filtration, in addition to left over crud
from neglect, casting sand bleeding out as castings erode ....
there is solids dropout and formation from the coolant itself.
Typically these are crystalised silica and silaca gel.
Both stationary and OTR diesels commonly use coolant filtration
and even have filters that introduce anti-corrosion additives back
into the coolant during use.
Factory coolant filters are also found in pleasure craft and aircraft.
The following users liked this post:
ronbros (12-12-2016)
#10
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,911
Received 10,969 Likes
on
7,207 Posts
Lots of cooling systems have debris floating around. How much of a problem this presents depends on how much debris there is and how worried you want to be about it. If really clean fluids are important to you, you can filter the coolant and rest more easily.
I've drained supposedly clean cooling systems and then poured the old coolant thru a paint filter and have been surprised I what I saw.
I'll try to find some pics, from others, showing what was captured in the Tefba filters when they were all the rage.
OTOH, cooling systems are not as delicate as, let's say, fuel systems....so they can tolerate a certain amount of debris with no ill consequences.
I've never used a coolant filter personally but it's hard to argue very strongly against the filtering of fluids IMO
Cheers
DD
#11
has to flow. The crud just flows around relatively large passages unlike
engine oil around journals.
However, the solids are no friend to water pump seals when they
crystallise and no friend to heater cores when they settle out.
Any silica would definitely not be impeller friendly, with or without
cavitation.
Water pumps are relatively cheap and easy to replace, so no one
complains too much when they wear out. Imagine the hue and cry
if instead it was the crank.
Last edited by plums; 12-10-2016 at 01:18 PM.
#12
100% agree. Coolant filters are a complete waste of effort and quite unnecessary. At best they mask a system full of rubbish that needs a proper flush and service.
Also, shoving a great big filter like that into the circuit is bound to affect coolant flow and pressure adversely, a risk I think it would be unwise to take with the engine. Believe me, the risk to your engine from a blocked filter is infinitely greater than from a bit of crud at the bottom of the rad or the block. My car has done 130,000 miles over 32 years and has never had one.
Greg
Also, shoving a great big filter like that into the circuit is bound to affect coolant flow and pressure adversely, a risk I think it would be unwise to take with the engine. Believe me, the risk to your engine from a blocked filter is infinitely greater than from a bit of crud at the bottom of the rad or the block. My car has done 130,000 miles over 32 years and has never had one.
Greg
Isn't the flow to the heater core controlled by that valve just up from the outlined pipe anyway? Id imagine a filter on a hose like that wouldnt be so bad its not like its on the main inlets to the radiator
#13
My XJ8 has now next to 200.000 km and is 20 years old... I have had to work on the cooling system a couple of times (once replacing two hoses under the intake manifold together with the thermostat housing, then I had to replace the hoses to and from the radiator and finally I drained the system to change the chains).
The coolant was absolutely prestine each time and there is no limescale or so inside - even though I use tap water (my area has dreadfully hard water) and cheap antifreeze. No filter required. The radiator isn't clogged up nor is there anything in there to justify putting in a filter...
It is, as Greg and I agree on, always to do with regular maintance. Coolant NEEDS to be replaced around every 2-3 years. No matter on what engine. No matter how much you drive or where you live. You could live in Siberia or in Death Valley, the antifreeze still needs changing. If you simply ignore the fact, you get build up in the channels and radiators.
But IF you were wanting to fit a filter, then you want the heater outlet. You can grab that, if you open the bonnet, on the LEFT side of the engine (the side with the crank case ventilation) and follow a black pipe, which runs alongside the main chassis arm. The pipe ends at the front near the radiator. This is the ideal take off, as it is rather low down and you can possibly fit a small filter down there without restricting the flow of water. It is sucked and pumped there at the same time...
The coolant was absolutely prestine each time and there is no limescale or so inside - even though I use tap water (my area has dreadfully hard water) and cheap antifreeze. No filter required. The radiator isn't clogged up nor is there anything in there to justify putting in a filter...
It is, as Greg and I agree on, always to do with regular maintance. Coolant NEEDS to be replaced around every 2-3 years. No matter on what engine. No matter how much you drive or where you live. You could live in Siberia or in Death Valley, the antifreeze still needs changing. If you simply ignore the fact, you get build up in the channels and radiators.
But IF you were wanting to fit a filter, then you want the heater outlet. You can grab that, if you open the bonnet, on the LEFT side of the engine (the side with the crank case ventilation) and follow a black pipe, which runs alongside the main chassis arm. The pipe ends at the front near the radiator. This is the ideal take off, as it is rather low down and you can possibly fit a small filter down there without restricting the flow of water. It is sucked and pumped there at the same time...
#14
While we're on the subject of cooling systems are there any real downsides to putting a small shop vac to the radiator inlets and forcefully sucking the coolant/crud back out the top? My car tends to run hot even after multiple flushes I wondered if its just the top of the rad thats full of crap.
#15
Join Date: Oct 2009
Location: Perth Ontario Canada
Posts: 11,058
Received 2,265 Likes
on
1,845 Posts
What problem are you trying to fix?
#16
While we're on the subject of cooling systems are there any real downsides to putting a small shop vac to the radiator inlets and forcefully sucking the coolant/crud back out the top? My car tends to run hot even after multiple flushes I wondered if its just the top of the rad thats full of crap.
These engines will cool nicely when cared for. The system though is a little "tricky" so be aware... I'd go through a few things to see what could help:
1. thermostats
Are they working right? Are they old and maybe not opening far enough? Do they open at all?
2. air pockets
Has the cooling system been blead right? These cars don't self-blead so you need to manually let the air out. I think either Greg or Grant posted the most effective way to blead (lift front left wheel off the ground, with engine running, open blead screw, let air out until it pees water everywhere, done - that is the short way). Air pockets will cause heat spots...
3. blocked radiator
The best system will only work if the radiator can provide enough flow. If it is blocked due to sediments blocking the vains, then it will effect the cooling. You can remove the radiator and reverse flush it (bottom exit, pump water into it, the worst of the worse will come out or better should). If that doesn't work, a recore will also be a good choice...
Most people though seem to think the engine runs too warm. Most of the time it doesn't and only the gauge is making it look bad. Best way would be to get an infrared thermometer and see what the engine really has for temperatures...
#17
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,911
Received 10,969 Likes
on
7,207 Posts
#18
Join Date: Mar 2008
Location: Pacific Northwest USA
Posts: 24,911
Received 10,969 Likes
on
7,207 Posts
A couple examples
http://www.brianschreurs.org/neptune...s/sctee375.jpg
http://www.jag-lovers.org/xj-s/book/GanoCleanout.jpg
Cheers
DD
http://www.brianschreurs.org/neptune...s/sctee375.jpg
http://www.jag-lovers.org/xj-s/book/GanoCleanout.jpg
Cheers
DD
#19
For what it's worth, I raised the issue of coolant filters with my garage, who work on Ferraris and Porsches and other high-end European cars (plus one old Jag) and the guy was adamant that it was not worth it.
I tend to agree with those who say it's better just to flush and replace every so often. Thinking about it, if coolant filters were so vital, wouldn't they be standard, like oil filters?
I tend to agree with those who say it's better just to flush and replace every so often. Thinking about it, if coolant filters were so vital, wouldn't they be standard, like oil filters?
#20
It comes down to upper management/cost controls vs engineers.
See the following video as evidence of what I'm referring to
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XfVq...ature=youtu.be
See the following video as evidence of what I'm referring to
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XfVq...ature=youtu.be