Do You Guys Like the Slightly Taller Optional Wing?
#1
Do You Guys Like the Slightly Taller Optional Wing?
Peeps,
I'm debating ordering that slightly higher duck wing like on the 175. I didn't too much like the sharp edges of the ground effects on the 175 as they look like a ground effects kit and IMHO disrupt the clean lines.
But the spoiler may work. It is a bit more aggressive and with my car being lowered, exhaust, diffuser and wheels soon to come I am thinking it could work.
Thoughts?
I'm debating ordering that slightly higher duck wing like on the 175. I didn't too much like the sharp edges of the ground effects on the 175 as they look like a ground effects kit and IMHO disrupt the clean lines.
But the spoiler may work. It is a bit more aggressive and with my car being lowered, exhaust, diffuser and wheels soon to come I am thinking it could work.
Thoughts?
#3
Peeps,
I'm debating ordering that slightly higher duck wing like on the 175. I didn't too much like the sharp edges of the ground effects on the 175 as they look like a ground effects kit and IMHO disrupt the clean lines.
But the spoiler may work. It is a bit more aggressive and with my car being lowered, exhaust, diffuser and wheels soon to come I am thinking it could work.
Thoughts?
I'm debating ordering that slightly higher duck wing like on the 175. I didn't too much like the sharp edges of the ground effects on the 175 as they look like a ground effects kit and IMHO disrupt the clean lines.
But the spoiler may work. It is a bit more aggressive and with my car being lowered, exhaust, diffuser and wheels soon to come I am thinking it could work.
Thoughts?
#4
#6
I like the whole speed pack kit that is on the XKR 175...o I like the bigger spoiler.
I don't know what it would look like without the rear diffuser/valence...the bigger spoiler will add some additional "perspective" which will draw the eye and may produce an unbalanced look. Not sure...just thinking out loud.
This is along the same lines of blacking out the chrome blade, which allows a more balanced look of the rear of the car...without the chrome blade the eyes aren't drawn in to the center of the cars rear and you "see" a wider, sexier rear end.
I don't know what it would look like without the rear diffuser/valence...the bigger spoiler will add some additional "perspective" which will draw the eye and may produce an unbalanced look. Not sure...just thinking out loud.
This is along the same lines of blacking out the chrome blade, which allows a more balanced look of the rear of the car...without the chrome blade the eyes aren't drawn in to the center of the cars rear and you "see" a wider, sexier rear end.
#7
Also, I forgot to say, the spoiler has an antenna in it on the 2010-11 XK/R's, so you will have to order your spoiler from Jaguar (Part No. C2P22257XXX) in order to get the built in antenna.
The Mina spoiler will not work since you cannot re-use the antenna that is integrated with your existing spoiler.
I verified this with Jaguar/Landrover of Northpoint in Roswell, GA.
So the spoiler I bought from Mina will not work on my 2010. It would be fine for 2007 - 2009 XK/R's...
The Mina spoiler will not work since you cannot re-use the antenna that is integrated with your existing spoiler.
I verified this with Jaguar/Landrover of Northpoint in Roswell, GA.
So the spoiler I bought from Mina will not work on my 2010. It would be fine for 2007 - 2009 XK/R's...
Last edited by rscultho; 04-28-2013 at 05:30 PM.
Trending Topics
#8
I like the larger spoiler as I've had it on my car for almost 3 years now. It makes it more sporty as my OEM spoiler looks alittle too small IMO.
Here's what it looks like unpainted. I went with the OEM larger spoiler (not the Mina): https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/x...spoiler-36866/
Smaller (whem my car was stock) vs Larger Spoiler (current):
Here's what it looks like unpainted. I went with the OEM larger spoiler (not the Mina): https://www.jaguarforums.com/forum/x...spoiler-36866/
Smaller (whem my car was stock) vs Larger Spoiler (current):
Last edited by GhostriderXKR08; 04-23-2013 at 01:58 PM.
#9
I agree the larger spoiler may need the diffuser to balance. Although the Speed Pack doesn't have the Mina or RS diffuser.
I ordered the same diffuser as on Ghostrider's car. But Mina just mentioned a carbon fiber version that is just the middle part and bolts right on. So the wrap look that results in the ridge down the side of rear bumper won't be there. It would remain smooth on the sides but with diffuser in middle. This may work better for me as I don't plan on adding the side skirts as I like a very clean look. I don't think even the RS has the same sharp side skirts that Mina sells does it?
Anyhow, I like the the center kit will be Carbon. Here is a rendering Mina provided me. The top is the rendering, the bottom is the RS for comparison. You can also see Ghost's pic and note the wraparound that will be gone.
I ordered the same diffuser as on Ghostrider's car. But Mina just mentioned a carbon fiber version that is just the middle part and bolts right on. So the wrap look that results in the ridge down the side of rear bumper won't be there. It would remain smooth on the sides but with diffuser in middle. This may work better for me as I don't plan on adding the side skirts as I like a very clean look. I don't think even the RS has the same sharp side skirts that Mina sells does it?
Anyhow, I like the the center kit will be Carbon. Here is a rendering Mina provided me. The top is the rendering, the bottom is the RS for comparison. You can also see Ghost's pic and note the wraparound that will be gone.
The following users liked this post:
MaximA (12-29-2013)
#10
I agree the larger spoiler may need the diffuser to balance. Although the Speed Pack doesn't have the Mina or RS diffuser.
I ordered the same diffuser as on Ghostrider's car. But Mina just mentioned a carbon fiber version that is just the middle part and bolts right on. So the wrap look that results in the ridge down the side of rear bumper won't be there. It would remain smooth on the sides but with diffuser in middle. This may work better for me as I don't plan on adding the side skirts as I like a very clean look. I don't think even the RS has the same sharp side skirts that Mina sells does it?
Anyhow, I like the the center kit will be Carbon. Here is a rendering Mina provided me. The top is the rendering, the bottom is the RS for comparison. You can also see Ghost's pic and note the wraparound that will be gone.
Attachment 40592
I ordered the same diffuser as on Ghostrider's car. But Mina just mentioned a carbon fiber version that is just the middle part and bolts right on. So the wrap look that results in the ridge down the side of rear bumper won't be there. It would remain smooth on the sides but with diffuser in middle. This may work better for me as I don't plan on adding the side skirts as I like a very clean look. I don't think even the RS has the same sharp side skirts that Mina sells does it?
Anyhow, I like the the center kit will be Carbon. Here is a rendering Mina provided me. The top is the rendering, the bottom is the RS for comparison. You can also see Ghost's pic and note the wraparound that will be gone.
Attachment 40592
Please post pics and give us a review once you have it on...
#17
I agree the larger spoiler may need the diffuser to balance. Although the Speed Pack doesn't have the Mina or RS diffuser.
I ordered the same diffuser as on Ghostrider's car. But Mina just mentioned a carbon fiber version that is just the middle part and bolts right on. So the wrap look that results in the ridge down the side of rear bumper won't be there. It would remain smooth on the sides but with diffuser in middle. This may work better for me as I don't plan on adding the side skirts as I like a very clean look. I don't think even the RS has the same sharp side skirts that Mina sells does it?
Anyhow, I like the the center kit will be Carbon. Here is a rendering Mina provided me. The top is the rendering, the bottom is the RS for comparison. You can also see Ghost's pic and note the wraparound that will be gone.
Attachment 40592
I ordered the same diffuser as on Ghostrider's car. But Mina just mentioned a carbon fiber version that is just the middle part and bolts right on. So the wrap look that results in the ridge down the side of rear bumper won't be there. It would remain smooth on the sides but with diffuser in middle. This may work better for me as I don't plan on adding the side skirts as I like a very clean look. I don't think even the RS has the same sharp side skirts that Mina sells does it?
Anyhow, I like the the center kit will be Carbon. Here is a rendering Mina provided me. The top is the rendering, the bottom is the RS for comparison. You can also see Ghost's pic and note the wraparound that will be gone.
Attachment 40592
#19
Just as an FYI - the full Speed Pack kit decreases lift by 25%. The R-S kit (bigger wing, bigger splitter) only improves that by 1%. The Speed Pack's high-speed stability is impressive.
If you want the aero improvements, I suspect that fitting the Speed Pack or a close equivalent is the way to go - and that would be the whole pack, front, sides & rear, to get the full effect. Leaving off the side skirts, for example, will take away a lot of the benefit.
However, if you're just looking for aesthetic tweaks, then it's a matter of taste, and the aero considerations are not material.
If you want the aero improvements, I suspect that fitting the Speed Pack or a close equivalent is the way to go - and that would be the whole pack, front, sides & rear, to get the full effect. Leaving off the side skirts, for example, will take away a lot of the benefit.
However, if you're just looking for aesthetic tweaks, then it's a matter of taste, and the aero considerations are not material.
The following users liked this post:
MaximA (12-30-2013)
#20
Of course I'm going on the pics only, which I acknowledge can be deceiving, but I prefer the smaller rear wing over the taller one. The latter changes the perfect curve from fender to fender and looks like an add-on, which opposes the natural flow of the lines. I'm not being critical, but rather stating my personal tastes.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)