Convertible top latch hydraulic problem
#581
Haven't put my top down yet but have seen dealer pictures with it down and he said it works but I am afraid to try in cold weather as this may put more stress on the hoses. I've seen replacement springs for the pressure regulator in the pump. Should I replace the OEM springs for the latch mechanism and the lift cylinders and will this reduced pressure significantly slow the top operation?
Yessir, replacing the spring gets you pressure reduction for $2.00. I keep a supply of springs on hand. Link in sig. line below.
This does not effect how fast the top operates. Pressures about the same in hot or cold weather.
(I agree ... be sure this or any system is working correctly before modifying it.)
Last edited by Dennis07; 01-10-2015 at 07:41 AM.
#584
It would be a pretty good engineering challenge to integrate an electric actuator into the old design as there is very little space in the header. The existing hydraulic actuator pulls down the claw with considerable force to lock and seal the top and it is physically quite small for the power it develops with over 1000 PSI driving it. Then, it would also have to be integrated with the existing computer controlled top control system which is split across 3 different multi--function electronic modules (the BCP, the SLM and the Driver door Module.)
Last edited by WhiteXKR; 01-11-2015 at 03:27 PM.
#585
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: PHX some of the time
Posts: 117,265
Received 6,307 Likes
on
5,495 Posts
#586
WhiteXKR, the control signalling would probably be the easier part; either tap into the signal to the pump that causes it to pump fluid into the latch hoses, or put a pressure switch on the latch hose at the pump. It sounds like the physical latch would be the more difficult part. You could possibly mount a motor under the dash and run a drive cable to the latch...but may not be worth the trouble since the relief valve modification seems to avert the biggest issue.
#587
#588
Not looking for any way out. Was just curious why Jaguar had not used electrics to begin with, and asked if anyone had tried that conversion. According to WhiteXKR, apparently Jaguar decided it was a better way to go with the 2007 MY. More of a thought exercise than anything else for our vehicles. I have already installed the pressure relief valve for my car. Sorry if I revived an old debate.
#589
Not looking for any way out. Was just curious why Jaguar had not used electrics to begin with, and asked if anyone had tried that conversion. According to WhiteXKR, apparently Jaguar decided it was a better way to go with the 2007 MY. More of a thought exercise than anything else for our vehicles. I have already installed the pressure relief valve for my car. Sorry if I revived an old debate.
I guess the design in the XK150 vehicles wisely totally eliminates hoses running all over the vehicle from front to rear.
Doug
#590
#591
Never be sorry for good dialogue.
Not looking for any way out. Was just curious why Jaguar had not used electrics to begin with, and asked if anyone had tried that conversion. According to WhiteXKR, apparently Jaguar decided it was a better way to go with the 2007 MY. More of a thought exercise than anything else for our vehicles. I have already installed the pressure relief valve for my car. Sorry if I revived an old debate.
#592
He's got a point, but some reprieves are out there too ...
- the earliest cars had hoses that seem to last.
- UK and other cool-climate cars seem to avoid the green shower too. (I'm convinced it's primarily temperature.)
I've run two XK8s, both with original hoses, over an eight-year span now with no failures. (Knock, knock.) Just lucky maybe, but I have taken precautions.
Aside from hoses, I've developed a grudging respect for this system. The pump is bullet-proof; can't recall a failure reported. Similarly, the two flow-control valves (provided we're careful not to whack their fragile connectors). Beyond that it's hoses (criminal), three hydraulic cylinders (reliability in line with industry), and a few limit switches (same). The "Modules" which control this stuff seem quite reliable.
There are only so many things that go wrong. I can think of only one trouble reported here that didn't get sorted out (a previous owner had tried some creative re-wiring of components).
Last edited by Dennis07; 01-13-2015 at 05:22 PM.
#593
Jon,
He's got a point, but some reprieves are out there too ...
- the earliest cars had hoses that seem to last.
- UK and other cool-climate cars seem to avoid the green shower too. (I'm convinced it's primarily temperature.)
I've run two XK8s, both with original hoses, over an eight-year span now with no failures. (Knock, knock.) Just lucky maybe, but I have taken precautions.
Aside from hoses, I've developed a grudging respect for this system. The pump is bullet-proof; can't recall a failure reported. Similarly, the two flow-control valves (provided we're careful not to whack their fragile connectors). Beyond that it's hoses (criminal), three hydraulic cylinders (reliability in line with industry), and a few limit switches (same). The "Modules" which control this stuff seem quite reliable.
There are only so many things that go wrong. I can think of only one trouble reported here that didn't get sorted out (a previous owner had tried some creative re-wiring of components).
He's got a point, but some reprieves are out there too ...
- the earliest cars had hoses that seem to last.
- UK and other cool-climate cars seem to avoid the green shower too. (I'm convinced it's primarily temperature.)
I've run two XK8s, both with original hoses, over an eight-year span now with no failures. (Knock, knock.) Just lucky maybe, but I have taken precautions.
Aside from hoses, I've developed a grudging respect for this system. The pump is bullet-proof; can't recall a failure reported. Similarly, the two flow-control valves (provided we're careful not to whack their fragile connectors). Beyond that it's hoses (criminal), three hydraulic cylinders (reliability in line with industry), and a few limit switches (same). The "Modules" which control this stuff seem quite reliable.
There are only so many things that go wrong. I can think of only one trouble reported here that didn't get sorted out (a previous owner had tried some creative re-wiring of components).
And, oh yeah, about pump failures I guess you didn't see my post about the pump failure I had. And at $2,000 a pop for the part, another idiotic design.
Doug
#594
Since before 2008 when I joined this forum I have seen a few pump motors fail, several pump solenoids fail / broken many latch cylinders and lifts leaking along with failures and I am unable to say how many latch hoses and lift hoses that fail.
As for the cause in my opinion and research the hoses and seals were related and undersized for this application. Yes heat was a contributing factor but not the main reason for the failures, failures were reported in many different states and countries with varying climates.
So to say temperature is the major contributor to roof failures is incorrect you could say that temperature aided to a shorter life. Remember that the first set of hoses for this application are still in operation without failures so I would say that re-engineering by Jaguar/Power Packers to save money bit us in the ***!
As for the cause in my opinion and research the hoses and seals were related and undersized for this application. Yes heat was a contributing factor but not the main reason for the failures, failures were reported in many different states and countries with varying climates.
So to say temperature is the major contributor to roof failures is incorrect you could say that temperature aided to a shorter life. Remember that the first set of hoses for this application are still in operation without failures so I would say that re-engineering by Jaguar/Power Packers to save money bit us in the ***!
#595
I do recall pump motor issues --- wiring faults, brushes needed maybe -- but if there have been actual pump failures I missed them. (Some folks might not have looked further if the pump stopped running, and counted this as a pump failure. I don't know.)
I don't recall any control valve (solenoid) failures not caused by broken connectors. Can anyone cite one?
Whether temperature or pressure is the most important cause of hose failure cannot be determined by looking at failed parts and drawing an inference. We have to withhold judgement and let the statistics tell us. (Edwards Deming spent decades getting industry to understand this.) Of course there are some failures in all countries, climates, etc. With or without pressure modifying add-ons. What tells the tale is correlation. If we were to count up all the reported hose failures, and their circumstances, there's no doubt in my mind we'd find the strongest correlation with climate/temperature.
edit: Forgot ... the smoking gun concerning temperature is that the latch hoses fail much more often at the latch end than at the pump end. The same peak pressure exists in both spots, but temperatures differ greatly. The latch area gets much hotter.
I don't recall any control valve (solenoid) failures not caused by broken connectors. Can anyone cite one?
Whether temperature or pressure is the most important cause of hose failure cannot be determined by looking at failed parts and drawing an inference. We have to withhold judgement and let the statistics tell us. (Edwards Deming spent decades getting industry to understand this.) Of course there are some failures in all countries, climates, etc. With or without pressure modifying add-ons. What tells the tale is correlation. If we were to count up all the reported hose failures, and their circumstances, there's no doubt in my mind we'd find the strongest correlation with climate/temperature.
edit: Forgot ... the smoking gun concerning temperature is that the latch hoses fail much more often at the latch end than at the pump end. The same peak pressure exists in both spots, but temperatures differ greatly. The latch area gets much hotter.
Last edited by Dennis07; 01-14-2015 at 07:41 AM.
#596
#597
As an individual looking at the convertible top discussions and realizing difference of opinion take away from the fact we are all more knowledgable because some have gone the exta mile to find causes and solutions to our problem. Please understand how much we all can move forward with fixes on our cars because we know what each part is doing and how to either fix it ourselves or where to send them to be fixed.
As the cars are getting near the 10 year old mark and some 20, they are changing hands for many reasons and many buy them not knowing when or even if the hose, pump, ram or latch have been looked at. So what has gone before and why is really not the object, the biggest concern is how do we fix it and what can we do in helping it not happen again.
At present we have two methods of reducing pressure, several choices of hoses, rebuilt rams that are better than new and even a latch that can stand up to high pressure. The electrics are something to be handled with kid gloves and this will be a ongoing problem until someone starts to reproduce these connectors. Some are just buying Radio Shack plugs and connecting the wires on their plugs, works in many cases, but not all.
So, I'm just trying to say THANK YOU to Gus, Steve and Dennis07 for their work and concern, and ALL others that have given us their trails and errors, making us aware of what we will be getting into.
Thanks to all, and Yes, I'm getting ready to take the plunge. Wayne
As the cars are getting near the 10 year old mark and some 20, they are changing hands for many reasons and many buy them not knowing when or even if the hose, pump, ram or latch have been looked at. So what has gone before and why is really not the object, the biggest concern is how do we fix it and what can we do in helping it not happen again.
At present we have two methods of reducing pressure, several choices of hoses, rebuilt rams that are better than new and even a latch that can stand up to high pressure. The electrics are something to be handled with kid gloves and this will be a ongoing problem until someone starts to reproduce these connectors. Some are just buying Radio Shack plugs and connecting the wires on their plugs, works in many cases, but not all.
So, I'm just trying to say THANK YOU to Gus, Steve and Dennis07 for their work and concern, and ALL others that have given us their trails and errors, making us aware of what we will be getting into.
Thanks to all, and Yes, I'm getting ready to take the plunge. Wayne
#598
Tom, we had 3 pump motor failures that resulted in a pump replacements that I have been involved with along with 2 maybe 3 coil failures not related to the plugs being broken and 1 clogged coil orifice in all the time I have been dealing with the system. A broken plug is one that you are familiar with.
#599
#600
I think everyone agrees there have been no reported failures of the pump itself (unless we consider the motor driving it to be part of the pump; not an unreasonable thing to do). I may have pix of the pump mechanism, if anyone would like to see. Eccentric-ring based.
Can anyone cite post(s) describing control valve failures (other than broken terminals)? I can't seem to find any but have not looked all that hard.
Last edited by Dennis07; 01-14-2015 at 09:11 AM.