And the saga goes on.
#1
And the saga goes on.
Moved the Jag out of the garage to use the space to work on the house. Place to cut lumber etc... It has been on a battery tender all winter and the battery is a bit over a year old. After sitting for about 2 weeks I went to open the trunk and it wouldn't open. Battery DEAD! How can this be? What if I drove it to the airport and went on vacation for a few weeks? Come back to a car that won't start? 🤦*♂️
#2
Moved the Jag out of the garage to use the space to work on the house. Place to cut lumber etc... It has been on a battery tender all winter and the battery is a bit over a year old. After sitting for about 2 weeks I went to open the trunk and it wouldn't open. Battery DEAD! How can this be? What if I drove it to the airport and went on vacation for a few weeks? Come back to a car that won't start? 🤦*♂️
The following users liked this post:
Loxmth (05-13-2017)
#3
Join Date: Nov 2013
Location: Inverell, NSW, Australia
Posts: 3,052
Received 1,442 Likes
on
898 Posts
Maybe . . . maybe not . . . what was the actual battery voltage that you measured to make such a pronouncement? Wouldn't be the first that saw QCD drain a battery (PATS advice is a known cause) and if so, you need to perform QCD analysis (see Sticky How To in S-Type forum) but . . . also could be a fob tx/rx issue. Did you use key to open door? Was car then suffering flat battery or did it suddenly "wake up" and react normally?
Cheers,
Ken
Cheers,
Ken
#4
Maybe . . . maybe not . . . what was the actual battery voltage that you measured to make such a pronouncement? Wouldn't be the first that saw QCD drain a battery (PATS advice is a known cause) and if so, you need to perform QCD analysis (see Sticky How To in S-Type forum) but . . . also could be a fob tx/rx issue. Did you use key to open door? Was car then suffering flat battery or did it suddenly "wake up" and react normally?
Cheers,
Ken
Cheers,
Ken
#5
Join Date: Nov 2013
Location: Inverell, NSW, Australia
Posts: 3,052
Received 1,442 Likes
on
898 Posts
So . . . maybe the battery wasn't dead . . . likely, but not proven, and only a DVM measurement of standing battery voltage is diagnostic. Please believe my concern is to make sure you get the correct diagnosis . . . and if your car has a PATS issue, it will almost certainly recur despite the battery tender.
Best wishes,
Ken
Best wishes,
Ken
#6
So . . . maybe the battery wasn't dead . . . likely, but not proven, and only a DVM measurement of standing battery voltage is diagnostic. Please believe my concern is to make sure you get the correct diagnosis . . . and if your car has a PATS issue, it will almost certainly recur despite the battery tender.
Best wishes,
Ken
Best wishes,
Ken
I've been having many issues along the same lines for over a year. Most of them fixed temporary with a hard restart.
#9
Join Date: Nov 2013
Location: Inverell, NSW, Australia
Posts: 3,052
Received 1,442 Likes
on
898 Posts
That's why pronouncing the battery good, sick, bad, or dead is meaningless. The only reliable diagnostic is the measured standing battery voltage (<12.6V invites trouble) or, to be technically correct, also the measured cold cranking amperage (CCA) which dictates not just that the battery can crank and "start" the engine, but still have sufficient voltage headroom to successfully "start & run" all the car's electronics.
If we seem to bang on endlessly about this . . . well, you need the local auto shop to measure CCA, but spending $5-$10 for a DVM to DIY measure battery voltage is a no-brainer compared to the cost of a new battery.
Best wishes,
Ken
The following users liked this post:
jeremys (05-15-2017)
#10
#11
Join Date: Nov 2013
Location: Inverell, NSW, Australia
Posts: 3,052
Received 1,442 Likes
on
898 Posts
Hi Jeremy. Quick answer . . . normal if Jag has been hibernating for at least a week or more; abnormal if wanting to drive back home after a day's work.
As to whether this "hibernation" is normal or a "glitch" I have spent considerable time researching TSBs and all available manuals & docs re PATS. All I can point to are numerous posts reporting same here, usually as an initially assumed fault, and our shared experience on UK and ROW Jaguars of all models across that era, as confirmed previously . . . consistent and predictable. Perhaps it is also common on US/CAN imports? Perhaps not?
Cheers,
Ken
As to whether this "hibernation" is normal or a "glitch" I have spent considerable time researching TSBs and all available manuals & docs re PATS. All I can point to are numerous posts reporting same here, usually as an initially assumed fault, and our shared experience on UK and ROW Jaguars of all models across that era, as confirmed previously . . . consistent and predictable. Perhaps it is also common on US/CAN imports? Perhaps not?
Cheers,
Ken
The following users liked this post:
jeremys (05-15-2017)