top only tensioner replacement
#1
top only tensioner replacement
Recent (99) XK8 owner here. I notice that virtually all the recommendations and tutorials for replacement of the chain tensioners only replace the upper ones. do the lowers really not cause problems, or are they just not changes because of the difficulty involved?
Just curious,
Russ
Just curious,
Russ
#2
The following users liked this post:
GalaxyDriver (02-16-2015)
#3
Continuing the tensioner question
Thanks for bringing this up. I had been wondering the same thing, why emphasis on the secondary tensioners over the primaries. My "2002" XK8 manufacture month was June 2001. From information gathered on this forum, I believe I have the second generation, partial-plastic tensioners installed shortly before the transition to all aluminum tensioners in late summer 2001.
I still need to eyeball the tensioners to verify, but if I find plastic would others suggest changing the secondaries to all aluminum now and save changing the guides and primaries for a later date/higher mileage? I have with about 42000 miles now as the beauty sits in heated garage, hibernating with battery minder attached.
I still need to eyeball the tensioners to verify, but if I find plastic would others suggest changing the secondaries to all aluminum now and save changing the guides and primaries for a later date/higher mileage? I have with about 42000 miles now as the beauty sits in heated garage, hibernating with battery minder attached.
#4
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: PHX some of the time
Posts: 117,835
Received 6,366 Likes
on
5,539 Posts
The following users liked this post:
GalaxyDriver (02-16-2015)
#5
The following users liked this post:
GalaxyDriver (02-16-2015)
#6
The following users liked this post:
GalaxyDriver (02-17-2015)
#7
The difference to note on primary vs. secondary tensioners is that this is an interference engine. Meaning that if the secondary tensioners fail the engine bites itself and subsequently your wallet.
Failure of the primary tensioners will not cause the same level of damage and do give you some warning with a "rattle" at startup. The secondary tensioners will go without any warning with catastrophic results.
Failure of the primary tensioners will not cause the same level of damage and do give you some warning with a "rattle" at startup. The secondary tensioners will go without any warning with catastrophic results.
The following 2 users liked this post by Jag#4:
GalaxyDriver (02-17-2015),
Pristine97XK8Convertible (02-20-2015)
Trending Topics
#8
If you can DIY then a change of the secondary tensioners is essential. If you are going to fork out for a garage to do it then having the whole lot done has some advantages. Whilst the primary tensioners rarely show big problems, the guides do and should be replaced. Issues don't usually occur at less than 50K miles but I have never seen anyone post that at a greater mileage than this that their tensioners (1st or 2nd gen) didn't have cracks in the tensioners and guides.
The following users liked this post:
GalaxyDriver (02-17-2015)
#9
If you can DIY then a change of the secondary tensioners is essential. If you are going to fork out for a garage to do it then having the whole lot done has some advantages. Whilst the primary tensioners rarely show big problems, the guides do and should be replaced. Issues don't usually occur at less than 50K miles but I have never seen anyone post that at a greater mileage than this that their tensioners (1st or 2nd gen) didn't have cracks in the tensioners and guides.
The following users liked this post:
GalaxyDriver (02-17-2015)
#10
The car in question is currently mid-USA somewhere, in the belly of a transporter, and due to arrive here in Oregon in a couple more days, so I haven't been able to put an eyeball on it yet in person. will I be able to see the primary tensioners from the top with the valve covers off? The car is claimed to have had all it's upgrades and maintenance, but I was born a sceptic and like to see these things for myself . hopefully they were all upgraded with the aluminum parts already, and it will be a moot point.
Thanks for the input so far,
Russ
Thanks for the input so far,
Russ
#11
Here is a procedure for replacement of all chains, tensioners and guides. Lots of pictures.
Tmingi chain and tensioner replacement
Tmingi chain and tensioner replacement
The following 3 users liked this post by RJ237:
#12
Here is a procedure for replacement of all chains, tensioners and guides. Lots of pictures.
Tmingi chain and tensioner replacement
Tmingi chain and tensioner replacement
Russ
The following 3 users liked this post by Gus:
#15
Note, when you pull the Vcovers off you will pull the plug boots, beware any oil in these wells, if so you will need a seal kit (since u already have the vcover off it's easy) some have reused what was on but with the age I'd replace them so order that up first. You also might consider changing the plugs after you take a look... nothing is lifetime and better you know what you've got than something that may have been there awhile. I personally prefer the preventive maint scenario, if I'm working on something I'll fix/replace any other items while I'm there.
#16
Note, when you pull the Vcovers off you will pull the plug boots, beware any oil in these wells, if so you will need a seal kit (since u already have the vcover off it's easy) some have reused what was on but with the age I'd replace them so order that up first. You also might consider changing the plugs after you take a look... nothing is lifetime and better you know what you've got than something that may have been there awhile. I personally prefer the preventive maint scenario, if I'm working on something I'll fix/replace any other items while I'm there.
Russ
#17
Just a quick note about the differences in the upper and lower tensioners: The uppers have little plastic slipper "feet" on them, and these tend to shatter and fall off, leaving the upper chains slack and the chains riding on metal to metal. The upper bodies also tend to crack badly, as well. The lowers have only a "piston" that pushes against the chain guide to keep tension on the lower chains. The bodies of the lowers will also crack, but I cant say as I have seen one fail. What does fail are the guides. The crack and tend to separate. Usually after high mileage has been reached. So, if I had a relatively low mile car, I would do the uppers alone. If I had a high mileage car, I would do it all, and reseal the timing cover etc as well.
The following 3 users liked this post by chopr:
#18
Just a quick note about the differences in the upper and lower tensioners: The uppers have little plastic slipper "feet" on them, and these tend to shatter and fall off, leaving the upper chains slack and the chains riding on metal to metal. The upper bodies also tend to crack badly, as well. The lowers have only a "piston" that pushes against the chain guide to keep tension on the lower chains. The bodies of the lowers will also crack, but I cant say as I have seen one fail. What does fail are the guides. The crack and tend to separate. Usually after high mileage has been reached. So, if I had a relatively low mile car, I would do the uppers alone. If I had a high mileage car, I would do it all, and reseal the timing cover etc as well.
Russ
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
FS[Western US]: XJS Wiper Motor Upgrade- 76-88 - Electrolux Style
XJsc-guy
PRIVATE For Sale / Trade or Buy Classifieds
0
09-02-2015 11:43 AM
Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)