What LSD options do we have?
#1
What LSD options do we have?
I was driving spiritedly through some switchbacks today, and got the rear end to step out on a few occasions, in the dry. While I could control it, the most aggressive of those incidents caused the car to flop from left to right as one tire gained grip while the other lost grip. I know a limited-slip differential would have made all the difference in the world. Is our only option the Quaife unit?
#2
I was driving spiritedly through some switchbacks today, and got the rear end to step out on a few occasions, in the dry. While I could control it, the most aggressive of those incidents caused the car to flop from left to right as one tire gained grip while the other lost grip. I know a limited-slip differential would have made all the difference in the world. Is our only option the Quaife unit?
The the 15HU offset pinion diffs which predate the centreline pinion 14HU in our cars can be swapped over with a little work.
Quaife would probably be the easier option but then you are still left with the 14HU which is a somewhat weaker diff.
#4
#6
Ratio change is in the works currently. The Mercedes TCU is problematic in that reprogramming is no longer an option. A work around is available, (search this forum for "chirpy" post recently)l will know for sure soon enough. You can stick with same ratio but would need to fit appropriate ring gear and pinion to the 15HU.
#7
Ratio change is in the works currently. The Mercedes TCU is problematic in that reprogramming is no longer an option. A work around is available, (search this forum for "chirpy" post recently)l will know for sure soon enough. You can stick with same ratio but would need to fit appropriate ring gear and pinion to the 15HU.
Trending Topics
#8
I don't think you will find a 15HU easily with a 3.06 ratio. Getting a 3.58 ratio lsd 15HU from a '95-'97 XJR X300 seems to be the easiest.
With an HU15 you effectively have access to the Dana44 world of re-build/upgrade options, which are extensive.
If you change ratio, then it's possible the ABS spoofing work-around could work, but no-one has done it as far as I know.
The TCM does not know how fast the wheels are going around, it only knows the speeds of some of the input, internal shafts, and output shaft, depending on model.
So it seems to me that adjusting the ABS values fed to the TCM should work. An open question is if the ZF TCM does other checks (e.g. ABS reported speed, engine rpm correlation, or something else, in which case more signals might have to be manipulated - which could be done in the same way). So my guess is it will <probably> work, but I might be missing something.
With an HU15 you effectively have access to the Dana44 world of re-build/upgrade options, which are extensive.
If you change ratio, then it's possible the ABS spoofing work-around could work, but no-one has done it as far as I know.
The TCM does not know how fast the wheels are going around, it only knows the speeds of some of the input, internal shafts, and output shaft, depending on model.
So it seems to me that adjusting the ABS values fed to the TCM should work. An open question is if the ZF TCM does other checks (e.g. ABS reported speed, engine rpm correlation, or something else, in which case more signals might have to be manipulated - which could be done in the same way). So my guess is it will <probably> work, but I might be missing something.
#9
I don't think you will find a 15HU easily with a 3.06 ratio. Getting a 3.58 ratio lsd 15HU from a '95-'97 XJR X300 seems to be the easiest.
With an HU15 you effectively have access to the Dana44 world of re-build/upgrade options, which are extensive.
If you change ratio, then it's possible the ABS spoofing work-around could work, but no-one has done it as far as I know.
The TCM does not know how fast the wheels are going around, it only knows the speeds of some of the input, internal shafts, and output shaft, depending on model.
So it seems to me that adjusting the ABS values fed to the TCM should work. An open question is if the ZF TCM does other checks (e.g. ABS reported speed, engine rpm correlation, or something else, in which case more signals might have to be manipulated - which could be done in the same way). So my guess is it will <probably> work, but I might be missing something.
With an HU15 you effectively have access to the Dana44 world of re-build/upgrade options, which are extensive.
If you change ratio, then it's possible the ABS spoofing work-around could work, but no-one has done it as far as I know.
The TCM does not know how fast the wheels are going around, it only knows the speeds of some of the input, internal shafts, and output shaft, depending on model.
So it seems to me that adjusting the ABS values fed to the TCM should work. An open question is if the ZF TCM does other checks (e.g. ABS reported speed, engine rpm correlation, or something else, in which case more signals might have to be manipulated - which could be done in the same way). So my guess is it will <probably> work, but I might be missing something.
#10
The mechanical aspect of this swap I think I could manage, but spoofing the abs is out of my skill set and being the first one to try it is not very appealing to me when the result could be a bricked car and a loss of money I don't currently have. Is there a way of determining if this could work before going out to hunt for a suitable 15HU diff?
The following users liked this post:
giandanielxk8 (08-11-2021)
#11
I have started in the same place - try to prove out the electronics before tackling the mechanicals.
The way I have been doing it is to use a TCM that is programmed with the wrong ratio, and then adapt to it with the ABS signal modification.
But I was a lucky that I had a non-standard diff ratio and modified TCM, so I could buy a breaker yard stock TCM and work with that, without messing with the mechanicals.
So if you could find a different ratio TCM and install that, it would provide a way to test it out, if something suitable exists?
Not sure since I don't have a 6HP26, but I think the ZF TCM might be located inside the transmission, which would be inconvenient.
I think this transmission was used in BMWs, and maybe OEM'd by Ford? So perhaps there is someone out there that can reprogram the TCM to a different ratio, as an alternative?
The way I have been doing it is to use a TCM that is programmed with the wrong ratio, and then adapt to it with the ABS signal modification.
But I was a lucky that I had a non-standard diff ratio and modified TCM, so I could buy a breaker yard stock TCM and work with that, without messing with the mechanicals.
So if you could find a different ratio TCM and install that, it would provide a way to test it out, if something suitable exists?
Not sure since I don't have a 6HP26, but I think the ZF TCM might be located inside the transmission, which would be inconvenient.
I think this transmission was used in BMWs, and maybe OEM'd by Ford? So perhaps there is someone out there that can reprogram the TCM to a different ratio, as an alternative?
#12
The following 2 users liked this post by xalty:
DavidYau (08-11-2021),
giandanielxk8 (08-11-2021)
#13
I have started in the same place - try to prove out the electronics before tackling the mechanicals.
The way I have been doing it is to use a TCM that is programmed with the wrong ratio, and then adapt to it with the ABS signal modification.
But I was a lucky that I had a non-standard diff ratio and modified TCM, so I could buy a breaker yard stock TCM and work with that, without messing with the mechanicals.
So if you could find a different ratio TCM and install that, it would provide a way to test it out, if something suitable exists?
Not sure since I don't have a 6HP26, but I think the ZF TCM might be located inside the transmission, which would be inconvenient.
I think this transmission was used in BMWs, and maybe OEM'd by Ford? So perhaps there is someone out there that can reprogram the TCM to a different ratio, as an alternative?
The way I have been doing it is to use a TCM that is programmed with the wrong ratio, and then adapt to it with the ABS signal modification.
But I was a lucky that I had a non-standard diff ratio and modified TCM, so I could buy a breaker yard stock TCM and work with that, without messing with the mechanicals.
So if you could find a different ratio TCM and install that, it would provide a way to test it out, if something suitable exists?
Not sure since I don't have a 6HP26, but I think the ZF TCM might be located inside the transmission, which would be inconvenient.
I think this transmission was used in BMWs, and maybe OEM'd by Ford? So perhaps there is someone out there that can reprogram the TCM to a different ratio, as an alternative?
The spoofing approach should theoretically work, all of the communication is CAN based.
#14
Interesting information from all of you. I will have to see if converting the way xalty mentioned using the Dana 44 gears is less expensive than the Quaife ATB diff. On the other hand, if the spoofing works on the MB trans cars, it may provide some hope for the ZF cars as well. I would be nice to have a better ratio for getting the car moving... Also, I read somewhere that not all the 15HU diffs have Posi-trac. Is there any way of knowing if the 15HU in question is a Posi-trac?
#15
Interesting information from all of you. I will have to see if converting the way xalty mentioned using the Dana 44 gears is less expensive than the Quaife ATB diff. On the other hand, if the spoofing works on the MB trans cars, it may provide some hope for the ZF cars as well. I would be nice to have a better ratio for getting the car moving... Also, I read somewhere that not all the 15HU diffs have Posi-trac. Is there any way of knowing if the 15HU in question is a Posi-trac?
Definitely generalising here but start your search looking at XJR's and XJ12's, the others were mostly open diffs.
Last edited by baxtor; 08-11-2021 at 09:32 PM.
The following users liked this post:
giandanielxk8 (08-12-2021)
#16
They are marked on side of rear cover with stickers of various colours signifying ratio, if this sticker also has a black cross it means LSD. A metal tag across two of the diff's rear cover bolts also has that Info. Easiest way is still to jack both rear wheels of the ground and turn one wheel, LSD if both raised wheels rotate same direction, open diff if they rotate opposite each other.
Definitely generalising here but start your search looking at XJR's and XJ12's, the others were mostly open diffs.
Definitely generalising here but start your search looking at XJR's and XJ12's, the others were mostly open diffs.
#17
The following users liked this post:
giandanielxk8 (08-12-2021)
#18
I had one of the most highly modified XKR'S at one time. My car had the first of Avos's twin screw kits in the US. You can change the diff ratios from 3.27, 3.58 & 3.77. I was had all 3 fitted to my car over a period of time. The 3.27 was simply a Mexican spec XK8 unit & a straight bolt in. The 3.58 & 3.77 require the front diff mounting plate from a X300 as the diff is offset as well as a non jurid coupling. The 3.77 diff along with the blue top solenoids fitted to the transmission made the car a monster. The issue with changing the ratios is you need to reprogram the TCM. The only person that was able to do this was Phil @ Eurotek Designs. I would send him the TCM to someone in Germany that reprogrammed the unit. If I remember correctly it was about $2000. I always had a spare to send of so I was able to drive the car until all parts were assembled. The source for the 3.58 & 3.77 was Coventry West. I will say the LSD & gear ratio changes the dynamics of the car.
#19
......The issue with changing the ratios is you need to reprogram the TCM. The only person that was able to do this was Phil @ Eurotek Designs. I would send him the TCM to someone in Germany that reprogrammed the unit. If I remember correctly it was about $2000. I always had a spare to send of so I was able to drive the car until all parts were assembled. The source for the 3.58 & 3.77 was Coventry West. I will say the LSD & gear ratio changes the dynamics of the car.
Totally agree re the dynamics. In addition to acceleration improvement mentioned, my car is an R features vehicle and came with more direct steering rack so always had good feel but after fitting the LSD along with new clutch packs the steering feel improved even further. Highly recommend this conversion.
Last edited by baxtor; 09-23-2021 at 08:14 AM.
#20